David Einhorn Bullish on Peloton After Dip
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: 4 days ago
0mins
Should l Buy PTON?
Source: CNBC
- Overreaction by Investors: David Einhorn purchased Peloton stock after its latest earnings report, asserting that investors overreacted to the company's disappointing holiday quarter results, which caused a 26% drop in share price on Thursday, while he believes new management and an improving balance sheet will drive recovery.
- Historical Price Comparison: Peloton's stock peaked above $170 during the pandemic but has since plummeted to under $5; Einhorn argues that the stock has been unfairly punished and anticipates improvements in cash flow through cost-cutting and debt refinancing in the near future.
- Acadia Healthcare Outlook: Einhorn is also optimistic about Acadia Healthcare, suggesting that the return of a former successful CEO could help revive the stock, which has fallen from $80 to $13 in recent years, with potential for it to rebound significantly in the coming years.
- View on Housing Market: Einhorn expressed a negative outlook on the housing market, citing a structural decline due to housing shortages, rising rates, and affordability challenges, while mentioning he has high-conviction short positions that he does not plan to disclose.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy PTON?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on PTON
Wall Street analysts forecast PTON stock price to rise
12 Analyst Rating
4 Buy
8 Hold
0 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 4.230
Low
6.50
Averages
9.48
High
14.00
Current: 4.230
Low
6.50
Averages
9.48
High
14.00
About PTON
Peloton Interactive, Inc. is a global fitness company. The Company is a category innovator at the nexus of fitness, technology, and media, with a subscription platform that combines hardware, distinctive software, and exclusive content. Its segments include Connected Fitness Products and Subscription. The Company’s Connected Fitness Products portfolio includes the Peloton Bike, Bike+, Tread, Tread+, Guide, Row, and various Precor products. Access to the Peloton App is available with an All-Access or Guide Membership for Members who have Connected Fitness Products or through a standalone App Membership with multiple Membership tiers. Access to the Strength+ App is available with an All Access, Guide, or App+ Membership or through a standalone Strength+ subscription. The Company’s subscriptions provide access to Peloton content and its library of live and on-demand fitness classes. The Company’s subscriptions are offered on a month-to-month or prepaid basis.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Peloton Stock Declines 97% Amidst Struggles
- Financial Discipline Strengthened: Peloton exceeded its goal of achieving $200 million in annual cost savings in fiscal 2025, and despite laying off 11% of its workforce to control expenses, this reflects management's commitment to financial discipline, potentially laying the groundwork for future profitability.
- Free Cash Flow Recovery: The company reported free cash flow of $71 million in Q2 of fiscal 2026, up from $67 million in Q1, indicating an improvement in financial health after a prolonged period of cash burn, which may enhance investor confidence.
- Shrinking User Base: Despite launching the Cross Training series and an AI coaching platform, revenue fell 3% year-over-year in Q2 of fiscal 2026, with a declining subscriber base indicating limited growth potential in the high-priced fitness equipment market, leading to cautious investor sentiment.
- Declining Valuation Appeal: With a price-to-sales ratio below 0.8, Peloton's stock reflects low market expectations for future growth; although the valuation appears attractive, investors should remain cautious and avoid long-term holdings until consistent growth is observed.
See More
Peloton Shows Financial Improvement but Faces Grim Outlook
- Financial Improvement: Peloton achieved $200 million in annual run-rate cost savings in fiscal 2025, with management's focus on financial discipline leading to significant debt reduction and positive free cash flow, which reached $71 million in Q2 2026, indicating a proactive approach to financial management.
- Shrinking User Base: Despite launching the Cross Training Series and AI coaching platform, revenue in Q2 fiscal 2026 fell 3% year-over-year, with expectations of a similar decline for the full year, highlighting the ongoing challenge of a dwindling subscriber base that undermines investor confidence.
- Debt Reduction: Peloton's net debt decreased from $670 million a year ago to $319 million now, reflecting improvements in financial structure; however, persistent user attrition and declining revenues cast uncertainty on future growth prospects.
- Market Valuation: Peloton's stock trades at a price-to-sales ratio below 0.8, indicating market pessimism regarding its growth potential, and while the low valuation may seem attractive, investors should exercise caution in the absence of consistent growth.
See More
David Einhorn Bullish on Peloton After Dip
- Overreaction by Investors: David Einhorn purchased Peloton stock after its latest earnings report, asserting that investors overreacted to the company's disappointing holiday quarter results, which caused a 26% drop in share price on Thursday, while he believes new management and an improving balance sheet will drive recovery.
- Historical Price Comparison: Peloton's stock peaked above $170 during the pandemic but has since plummeted to under $5; Einhorn argues that the stock has been unfairly punished and anticipates improvements in cash flow through cost-cutting and debt refinancing in the near future.
- Acadia Healthcare Outlook: Einhorn is also optimistic about Acadia Healthcare, suggesting that the return of a former successful CEO could help revive the stock, which has fallen from $80 to $13 in recent years, with potential for it to rebound significantly in the coming years.
- View on Housing Market: Einhorn expressed a negative outlook on the housing market, citing a structural decline due to housing shortages, rising rates, and affordability challenges, while mentioning he has high-conviction short positions that he does not plan to disclose.
See More
Peloton Faces Sales Decline and Profitability Challenges
- Revenue Decline: In the first half of fiscal 2026, Peloton reported total revenue of $1.2 billion, a 4% decrease year-over-year, with equipment sales at $396 million and subscription revenue at $811 million, highlighting the company's struggle with demand post-pandemic.
- Cost-Cutting Success: Despite a staggering $2.8 billion net loss in fiscal 2022, Peloton managed to reduce operating expenses by 10% to $588 million in the first half of fiscal 2026, successfully avoiding bankruptcy risks and achieving a positive EBITDA of $199.7 million.
- Shrinking User Base: As of December 31, 2025, Peloton's connected fitness members decreased by 7% to 2.66 million, while paid app subscribers fell by 11% to 522,000, indicating waning consumer interest in its products.
- Debt and Cash Position: Peloton currently holds approximately $1.2 billion in cash but also carries $945 million in long-term debt, which limits its flexibility in marketing and experimenting with new strategies, raising concerns about future growth prospects.
See More
Peloton Stock Faces Long-Term Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales exceeded $4 billion in fiscal 2022, yet the recently reported second-quarter paid fitness subscriptions fell 7% year-over-year to under 2.7 million, indicating significant post-pandemic customer attrition that pressures revenue growth.
- Pricing Strategy Adjustment: Despite a decrease in subscribers, Peloton's management opted to raise prices, accompanied by some product enhancements; however, this strategy may exacerbate customer churn, leading to a 3% year-over-year revenue decline, reflecting the company's struggles in a competitive market.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million, yet ongoing losses and declining revenues raise investor concerns about its future prospects, potentially putting further pressure on the stock price.
- Valuation Trap Risk: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton may appear undervalued, but due to long-term competitive challenges, investors should exercise caution to avoid falling into a value trap.
See More
Peloton Faces Sales Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales surged to $915 million in fiscal 2020 and exceeded $4 billion by 2022, yet recent reports indicate a 7% year-over-year drop in paid fitness subscriptions, highlighting significant challenges in regaining growth momentum.
- Pricing Strategy Shift: Despite an increase in churn rates, Peloton's management opted to raise prices amid declining sales, reflecting confidence in product enhancements, but this strategy may exacerbate customer attrition risks.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million; however, a continued revenue decline of 3% year-over-year indicates that the company has yet to establish a viable path to profitability.
- Valuation Dilemma: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton's stock may appear undervalued, yet analysts caution that the long-term competitive pressures could render it a value trap, advising investors to tread carefully.
See More
Peloton Stock Declines 97% Amidst Struggles
- Financial Discipline Strengthened: Peloton exceeded its goal of achieving $200 million in annual cost savings in fiscal 2025, and despite laying off 11% of its workforce to control expenses, this reflects management's commitment to financial discipline, potentially laying the groundwork for future profitability.
- Free Cash Flow Recovery: The company reported free cash flow of $71 million in Q2 of fiscal 2026, up from $67 million in Q1, indicating an improvement in financial health after a prolonged period of cash burn, which may enhance investor confidence.
- Shrinking User Base: Despite launching the Cross Training series and an AI coaching platform, revenue fell 3% year-over-year in Q2 of fiscal 2026, with a declining subscriber base indicating limited growth potential in the high-priced fitness equipment market, leading to cautious investor sentiment.
- Declining Valuation Appeal: With a price-to-sales ratio below 0.8, Peloton's stock reflects low market expectations for future growth; although the valuation appears attractive, investors should remain cautious and avoid long-term holdings until consistent growth is observed.
See More
Peloton Shows Financial Improvement but Faces Grim Outlook
- Financial Improvement: Peloton achieved $200 million in annual run-rate cost savings in fiscal 2025, with management's focus on financial discipline leading to significant debt reduction and positive free cash flow, which reached $71 million in Q2 2026, indicating a proactive approach to financial management.
- Shrinking User Base: Despite launching the Cross Training Series and AI coaching platform, revenue in Q2 fiscal 2026 fell 3% year-over-year, with expectations of a similar decline for the full year, highlighting the ongoing challenge of a dwindling subscriber base that undermines investor confidence.
- Debt Reduction: Peloton's net debt decreased from $670 million a year ago to $319 million now, reflecting improvements in financial structure; however, persistent user attrition and declining revenues cast uncertainty on future growth prospects.
- Market Valuation: Peloton's stock trades at a price-to-sales ratio below 0.8, indicating market pessimism regarding its growth potential, and while the low valuation may seem attractive, investors should exercise caution in the absence of consistent growth.
See More
David Einhorn Bullish on Peloton After Dip
- Overreaction by Investors: David Einhorn purchased Peloton stock after its latest earnings report, asserting that investors overreacted to the company's disappointing holiday quarter results, which caused a 26% drop in share price on Thursday, while he believes new management and an improving balance sheet will drive recovery.
- Historical Price Comparison: Peloton's stock peaked above $170 during the pandemic but has since plummeted to under $5; Einhorn argues that the stock has been unfairly punished and anticipates improvements in cash flow through cost-cutting and debt refinancing in the near future.
- Acadia Healthcare Outlook: Einhorn is also optimistic about Acadia Healthcare, suggesting that the return of a former successful CEO could help revive the stock, which has fallen from $80 to $13 in recent years, with potential for it to rebound significantly in the coming years.
- View on Housing Market: Einhorn expressed a negative outlook on the housing market, citing a structural decline due to housing shortages, rising rates, and affordability challenges, while mentioning he has high-conviction short positions that he does not plan to disclose.
See More
Peloton Faces Sales Decline and Profitability Challenges
- Revenue Decline: In the first half of fiscal 2026, Peloton reported total revenue of $1.2 billion, a 4% decrease year-over-year, with equipment sales at $396 million and subscription revenue at $811 million, highlighting the company's struggle with demand post-pandemic.
- Cost-Cutting Success: Despite a staggering $2.8 billion net loss in fiscal 2022, Peloton managed to reduce operating expenses by 10% to $588 million in the first half of fiscal 2026, successfully avoiding bankruptcy risks and achieving a positive EBITDA of $199.7 million.
- Shrinking User Base: As of December 31, 2025, Peloton's connected fitness members decreased by 7% to 2.66 million, while paid app subscribers fell by 11% to 522,000, indicating waning consumer interest in its products.
- Debt and Cash Position: Peloton currently holds approximately $1.2 billion in cash but also carries $945 million in long-term debt, which limits its flexibility in marketing and experimenting with new strategies, raising concerns about future growth prospects.
See More
Peloton Stock Faces Long-Term Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales exceeded $4 billion in fiscal 2022, yet the recently reported second-quarter paid fitness subscriptions fell 7% year-over-year to under 2.7 million, indicating significant post-pandemic customer attrition that pressures revenue growth.
- Pricing Strategy Adjustment: Despite a decrease in subscribers, Peloton's management opted to raise prices, accompanied by some product enhancements; however, this strategy may exacerbate customer churn, leading to a 3% year-over-year revenue decline, reflecting the company's struggles in a competitive market.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million, yet ongoing losses and declining revenues raise investor concerns about its future prospects, potentially putting further pressure on the stock price.
- Valuation Trap Risk: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton may appear undervalued, but due to long-term competitive challenges, investors should exercise caution to avoid falling into a value trap.
See More
Peloton Faces Sales Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales surged to $915 million in fiscal 2020 and exceeded $4 billion by 2022, yet recent reports indicate a 7% year-over-year drop in paid fitness subscriptions, highlighting significant challenges in regaining growth momentum.
- Pricing Strategy Shift: Despite an increase in churn rates, Peloton's management opted to raise prices amid declining sales, reflecting confidence in product enhancements, but this strategy may exacerbate customer attrition risks.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million; however, a continued revenue decline of 3% year-over-year indicates that the company has yet to establish a viable path to profitability.
- Valuation Dilemma: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton's stock may appear undervalued, yet analysts caution that the long-term competitive pressures could render it a value trap, advising investors to tread carefully.
See More
