Class Action Lawsuit Raises Legal Risks for Upstart Holdings
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Jan 23 2026
0mins
Source: NASDAQ.COM
Upstart Holdings Inc. saw its stock price decline by 5.03% as it crossed below the 5-day SMA, reflecting investor concerns amid ongoing legal challenges.
The company is facing multiple class action lawsuits alleging that it made false and misleading statements regarding its AI underwriting model, Model 22, which has led to significant investor losses. These lawsuits claim that the inaccuracies in revenue guidance and risk assessments have undermined investor confidence, creating a challenging environment for the company as it seeks to recover from these legal issues.
As Upstart navigates these legal hurdles, the implications for its stock price could be significant, especially if the lawsuits lead to unfavorable outcomes. Investors are advised to monitor the situation closely as it unfolds.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy UPST?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on UPST
Wall Street analysts forecast UPST stock price to rise
13 Analyst Rating
7 Buy
4 Hold
2 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 30.460
Low
20.00
Averages
56.73
High
80.00
Current: 30.460
Low
20.00
Averages
56.73
High
80.00
About UPST
Upstart Holdings, Inc. is an artificial intelligence (AI) lending marketplace. The Company’s platform includes personal loans, automotive retail and refinance loans, home equity lines of credit (HELOCs), and small dollar loans. It applies artificial intelligence models and cloud applications to the process of underwriting consumer credit. Its AI marketplace connects consumers with its lending partner. Its consumers can access Upstart-powered loans via Upstart.com, through a lender-branded product on its lending partners’ own websites, and through auto dealerships that use its Upstart Auto Retail software. Its platform enables lenders provide a product their customers want, rather than letting customers seek loans from competitors. Its cloud-based software platform incorporates technologies and software development approaches to allow for development of new features, such as cloud-native technologies, data integrity and security, and configurable multi-tenant architecture, and others.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Nu Holdings: Three Catalysts for Potential Rebound in 2026
- Bank Charter Expansion: Nu Holdings is obtaining bank charters in Brazil and Mexico, with a total user base of 135 million, including 115 million in Brazil, positioning itself as the largest private financial institution, which is expected to enhance user engagement and stability through cross-selling.
- U.S. Market Expansion: The company has received a conditional bank charter to operate in the U.S., planning to fully capitalize within the next 12 to 18 months and offer a full range of banking products, targeting a vast market of 342 million potential customers.
- AI Credit Decision Optimization: Nu's AI model, Nuformer, has reduced credit risk by 70%, and in Q4 2025, the credit card purchase volume market share in Brazil increased by 0.5%, marking the highest absolute increase in a decade, demonstrating strong market performance and financial inclusion.
- International Brand Building: The partnership with Inter Miami CF and the naming of Nu Stadium signify the company's international growth strategy in the U.S., aimed at enhancing brand presence and attracting the large Spanish-speaking population.
See More
Nu Secures Bank Charters in Brazil and Mexico, Expands U.S. Ambitions
- Bank Charter Acquisition: Nu has secured full bank charters in Brazil and Mexico, allowing it to offer a wider range of financial products under one platform, thereby enhancing business stability and competitive positioning in the market.
- User Base Expansion: As of Q1, Nu boasts 115 million users in Brazil, covering over half of the adult population, demonstrating its strong appeal in a high-barrier market and providing opportunities for future cross-selling.
- U.S. Market Strategy: Nu has received a conditional bank charter to operate in the U.S., with plans to fully capitalize within the next 12 to 18 months, targeting the vast market of 342 million people to further drive its international growth strategy.
- AI Credit Scoring Innovation: Nu's AI model, Nuformer, has achieved a 70% reduction in risk, enhancing credit approval efficiency and improving credit quality, which is expected to lead to higher revenues and stronger market performance.
See More
Comparative Analysis of OneMain and Upstart
- OneMain's Steady Performance: OneMain's FY 2025 revenue reached nearly $6.2 billion, reflecting a 9.1% increase, with a net income of approximately $783 million and a net margin of 12.5%, indicating a stable recovery in the nonprime borrower market despite macroeconomic risks and competitive pressures.
- Upstart's Rapid Growth: Upstart's revenue surged nearly 59% in FY 2025 to about $1.1 billion, with a net income of roughly $53.6 million and a net margin close to 5.0%, marking a return to profitability after two years of losses, although its high customer concentration poses certain risks.
- Risk Profile Comparison: OneMain faces significant risks from adverse macroeconomic conditions, particularly regarding defaults among its nonprime borrower base, while Upstart relies heavily on a few key partners, and its AI models may encounter pricing errors during rapid economic shifts, adding uncertainty to its business.
- Valuation Differences: OneMain's forward P/E ratio stands at 7.8x, significantly lower than Upstart's 35.1x, highlighting its appeal to value-oriented investors, even as it experienced an uptick in delinquencies early in the year, while Upstart is projected to see a nearly 36% revenue increase in 2026, exceeding $1.4 billion.
See More
Comparative Analysis of OneMain and Upstart in Lending Market
- Profitability Comparison: OneMain's revenue for FY 2025 reached nearly $6.2 billion, reflecting a 9.1% increase year-over-year, with a net income of approximately $783 million and a net margin of 12.5%, showcasing its stable profitability in the nonprime lending market.
- Growth Potential Analysis: Upstart's revenue surged nearly 59% in FY 2025 to about $1.1 billion, achieving a net income of roughly $53.6 million and a net margin close to 5%, indicating strong growth potential for its AI-driven lending platform in a rapidly expanding market.
- Risk Assessment: OneMain faces significant risks from adverse macroeconomic conditions, particularly impacting its nonprime borrower base, while also contending with intense competition from larger financial institutions, which may lead to increased compliance costs.
- Market Outlook: Upstart is projected to see a nearly 36% revenue increase in 2026, exceeding $1.4 billion, compared to OneMain's expected 10% growth, suggesting that Upstart may be more competitive in the future market.
See More
Upstart Holdings Stock Fluctuations and Earnings Outlook
- Stock Performance: Upstart Holdings, Inc. (UPST) fell 4.06% to $30.50 in the latest session, underperforming the S&P 500's daily gain of 0.5%, indicating market caution regarding its short-term outlook.
- Monthly Growth: Despite the recent decline, UPST has increased by 7% over the past month, surpassing the Finance sector's gain of 1.89%, suggesting the company retains growth potential in a competitive market.
- Earnings Expectations: Upstart is forecasted to report an EPS of $0.55, reflecting a 52.78% increase from the prior year, with quarterly revenue expected to reach $354.89 million, up 37.93%, which could positively impact investor confidence.
- Valuation Analysis: Upstart's Forward P/E ratio stands at 14.02, significantly above the industry average of 10.68, while its PEG ratio of 0.34 indicates potential for future earnings growth, likely attracting investors seeking growth stocks.
See More
Upstart Leadership Changes and Price Target Adjustments
- Leadership Transition: Upstart announced a significant leadership change with co-founder and CTO Paul Gu becoming CEO on May 1, succeeding co-founder Dave Girouard, who will serve as Executive Chairman, indicating a long-term strategic succession plan within the company.
- Insider Trading Disclosure: President and Chief Capital Officer Sanjay Datta disclosed plans to sell 15,000 shares valued at approximately $456,000 in a Form 144 filing, alongside previous sales of 1,817 shares and 7,985 shares, reflecting a shift in executive confidence regarding the company's stock.
- Analyst Target Adjustments: Jefferies raised Upstart's price target from $27 to $30 while maintaining a 'Hold' rating, reflecting management's focus on core non-prime markets and new product developments, although this suggests a downside of about 3.4% from the stock's last close.
- Market Sentiment Analysis: Despite an 85% surge in message volume around Upstart stock in the past 24 hours, retail sentiment remains bearish, indicating cautious investor outlook as the stock has declined over 32% this year.
See More
Nu Holdings: Three Catalysts for Potential Rebound in 2026
- Bank Charter Expansion: Nu Holdings is obtaining bank charters in Brazil and Mexico, with a total user base of 135 million, including 115 million in Brazil, positioning itself as the largest private financial institution, which is expected to enhance user engagement and stability through cross-selling.
- U.S. Market Expansion: The company has received a conditional bank charter to operate in the U.S., planning to fully capitalize within the next 12 to 18 months and offer a full range of banking products, targeting a vast market of 342 million potential customers.
- AI Credit Decision Optimization: Nu's AI model, Nuformer, has reduced credit risk by 70%, and in Q4 2025, the credit card purchase volume market share in Brazil increased by 0.5%, marking the highest absolute increase in a decade, demonstrating strong market performance and financial inclusion.
- International Brand Building: The partnership with Inter Miami CF and the naming of Nu Stadium signify the company's international growth strategy in the U.S., aimed at enhancing brand presence and attracting the large Spanish-speaking population.
See More
Nu Secures Bank Charters in Brazil and Mexico, Expands U.S. Ambitions
- Bank Charter Acquisition: Nu has secured full bank charters in Brazil and Mexico, allowing it to offer a wider range of financial products under one platform, thereby enhancing business stability and competitive positioning in the market.
- User Base Expansion: As of Q1, Nu boasts 115 million users in Brazil, covering over half of the adult population, demonstrating its strong appeal in a high-barrier market and providing opportunities for future cross-selling.
- U.S. Market Strategy: Nu has received a conditional bank charter to operate in the U.S., with plans to fully capitalize within the next 12 to 18 months, targeting the vast market of 342 million people to further drive its international growth strategy.
- AI Credit Scoring Innovation: Nu's AI model, Nuformer, has achieved a 70% reduction in risk, enhancing credit approval efficiency and improving credit quality, which is expected to lead to higher revenues and stronger market performance.
See More
Comparative Analysis of OneMain and Upstart
- OneMain's Steady Performance: OneMain's FY 2025 revenue reached nearly $6.2 billion, reflecting a 9.1% increase, with a net income of approximately $783 million and a net margin of 12.5%, indicating a stable recovery in the nonprime borrower market despite macroeconomic risks and competitive pressures.
- Upstart's Rapid Growth: Upstart's revenue surged nearly 59% in FY 2025 to about $1.1 billion, with a net income of roughly $53.6 million and a net margin close to 5.0%, marking a return to profitability after two years of losses, although its high customer concentration poses certain risks.
- Risk Profile Comparison: OneMain faces significant risks from adverse macroeconomic conditions, particularly regarding defaults among its nonprime borrower base, while Upstart relies heavily on a few key partners, and its AI models may encounter pricing errors during rapid economic shifts, adding uncertainty to its business.
- Valuation Differences: OneMain's forward P/E ratio stands at 7.8x, significantly lower than Upstart's 35.1x, highlighting its appeal to value-oriented investors, even as it experienced an uptick in delinquencies early in the year, while Upstart is projected to see a nearly 36% revenue increase in 2026, exceeding $1.4 billion.
See More
Comparative Analysis of OneMain and Upstart in Lending Market
- Profitability Comparison: OneMain's revenue for FY 2025 reached nearly $6.2 billion, reflecting a 9.1% increase year-over-year, with a net income of approximately $783 million and a net margin of 12.5%, showcasing its stable profitability in the nonprime lending market.
- Growth Potential Analysis: Upstart's revenue surged nearly 59% in FY 2025 to about $1.1 billion, achieving a net income of roughly $53.6 million and a net margin close to 5%, indicating strong growth potential for its AI-driven lending platform in a rapidly expanding market.
- Risk Assessment: OneMain faces significant risks from adverse macroeconomic conditions, particularly impacting its nonprime borrower base, while also contending with intense competition from larger financial institutions, which may lead to increased compliance costs.
- Market Outlook: Upstart is projected to see a nearly 36% revenue increase in 2026, exceeding $1.4 billion, compared to OneMain's expected 10% growth, suggesting that Upstart may be more competitive in the future market.
See More
Upstart Holdings Stock Fluctuations and Earnings Outlook
- Stock Performance: Upstart Holdings, Inc. (UPST) fell 4.06% to $30.50 in the latest session, underperforming the S&P 500's daily gain of 0.5%, indicating market caution regarding its short-term outlook.
- Monthly Growth: Despite the recent decline, UPST has increased by 7% over the past month, surpassing the Finance sector's gain of 1.89%, suggesting the company retains growth potential in a competitive market.
- Earnings Expectations: Upstart is forecasted to report an EPS of $0.55, reflecting a 52.78% increase from the prior year, with quarterly revenue expected to reach $354.89 million, up 37.93%, which could positively impact investor confidence.
- Valuation Analysis: Upstart's Forward P/E ratio stands at 14.02, significantly above the industry average of 10.68, while its PEG ratio of 0.34 indicates potential for future earnings growth, likely attracting investors seeking growth stocks.
See More
Upstart Leadership Changes and Price Target Adjustments
- Leadership Transition: Upstart announced a significant leadership change with co-founder and CTO Paul Gu becoming CEO on May 1, succeeding co-founder Dave Girouard, who will serve as Executive Chairman, indicating a long-term strategic succession plan within the company.
- Insider Trading Disclosure: President and Chief Capital Officer Sanjay Datta disclosed plans to sell 15,000 shares valued at approximately $456,000 in a Form 144 filing, alongside previous sales of 1,817 shares and 7,985 shares, reflecting a shift in executive confidence regarding the company's stock.
- Analyst Target Adjustments: Jefferies raised Upstart's price target from $27 to $30 while maintaining a 'Hold' rating, reflecting management's focus on core non-prime markets and new product developments, although this suggests a downside of about 3.4% from the stock's last close.
- Market Sentiment Analysis: Despite an 85% surge in message volume around Upstart stock in the past 24 hours, retail sentiment remains bearish, indicating cautious investor outlook as the stock has declined over 32% this year.
See More
