SA Quant Rankings of Leading Homebuilding Stocks Following Toll Brothers' Q4 Earnings Report
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Dec 09 2025
0mins
Source: SeekingAlpha
Toll Brothers Earnings Report: Toll Brothers (TOL) stock fell after Q4 earnings missed Wall Street expectations, reporting an EPS of $4.58 compared to the estimated $4.89, largely due to delays in selling its Apartment Living business stake.
Top Homebuilding Stocks: Seeking Alpha’s Quant Ratings ranked Cavco Industries (CVCO) highest at 4.35, followed by Green Brick Partners (GRBK) at 4.19 and Champion Homes (SKY) at 3.99, all receiving "Buy" ratings.
Quant Rating System: The Quant system evaluates stocks based on performance metrics like valuation and growth, with ratings above 3.5 considered bullish and those below 2.5 viewed as bearish.
Additional Homebuilding Stocks: Other notable stocks include Installed Building Products (IBP) and Century Communities (CCS), both rated as "Hold" with scores of 3.29 and 3.24, respectively.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy TOL?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on TOL
Wall Street analysts forecast TOL stock price to fall
13 Analyst Rating
7 Buy
5 Hold
1 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 153.270
Low
110.00
Averages
150.00
High
181.00
Current: 153.270
Low
110.00
Averages
150.00
High
181.00
About TOL
Toll Brothers, Inc. is a builder of luxury homes. The Company builds new homes and communities in over 60 markets across the United States, serving first-time, move-up, active-adult, and second-home buyers. The Company also operates its own architectural, engineering, mortgage, title, land development, smart home technology, landscape, and building components manufacturing businesses. It designs, builds, markets, sells, and arranges financing for an array of luxury residential single-family detached, attached, master-planned, resort-style golf, and urban low-, mid-, and high-rise communities. It also develops and operates urban and suburban for-rent apartment and student housing communities (Apartment Living) primarily through joint ventures. These projects are located in various metropolitan areas throughout the country and have generally been operated or developed with partners under the brand names Toll Brothers Apartment Living and Toll Brothers Campus Living.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Toll Brothers Announces Final Home Buying Opportunity
- Final Buying Opportunity: Toll Brothers announces that fewer than 15 luxury homes remain available at the Regency at Caramella Ranch community in South Reno, with prices starting from the upper $600,000s, attracting many buyers seeking a premium lifestyle.
- Community Features: The community offers luxury single-level home designs ranging from 1,680 to over 2,760 square feet, featuring 2 to 3 bedrooms and garages, catering to diverse family needs and enhancing living flexibility and comfort.
- Abundant Amenities: Regency at Caramella Ranch provides a resort-style lifestyle with amenities such as a large clubhouse, indoor lap pool, fitness center, and multi-tiered resort-style pool, significantly enhancing residents' social activities and quality of life.
- Strategic Location: Located within an hour of Lake Tahoe and close to golf courses and shopping centers, the community offers a convenient living environment while benefiting from no state income tax, drawing increased interest from potential homebuyers.
See More
Dow Industrials Hits New Record High Amid Market Movements
- Housing Market Trends: Toll Brothers has risen about 18% in the past month, despite a decline of 11% from February's peak, indicating volatility in the market and shifts in investor confidence.
- SpaceX Stock Performance: On its second day of trading, SpaceX gained nearly 20%, closing at $192.50 with a market cap of $2.5 trillion, reflecting strong market expectations for its future growth.
- Energy Market Review: West Texas Intermediate crude futures have dipped below $80, up over 20% since late February, yet the energy sector has declined 7.3% in the past month, highlighting market uncertainties.
- Market Indices New Highs: The Dow Industrials and NYSE Composite both hit new highs, rising nearly 11% and 7.3% over the past three months, respectively, showcasing robust overall market performance.
See More
Abel's First Acquisition: Taylor Morrison Purchase
- First Major Acquisition: Greg Abel, who took over as CEO in 2026, announced the $6.8 billion acquisition of Taylor Morrison on May 31, marking his first significant move, although market interpretations of this acquisition may be overstated.
- Market Reaction Analysis: The acquisition is not driven by expectations of a housing market rebound but rather by Taylor Morrison's relatively low valuation, with a current price-to-sales ratio of approximately 0.9x, compared to other major builders' ratios of 1.3x to 1.4x, indicating its attractiveness.
- Integration Strategy Intent: Abel explicitly stated in the announcement that he plans to unify Berkshire's homebuilding operations into a cohesive platform to better serve American homeowners, indicating a shift towards a more hands-on management approach.
- Long-Term Investment Perspective: While the $6.8 billion acquisition is relatively small for Berkshire's nearly $1 trillion market cap, considering its nearly $400 billion cash reserves, this move is more likely a strategic long-term investment rather than a bet on short-term market fluctuations.
See More
Berkshire Hathaway's Strategic Acquisition of Taylor Morrison
- Acquisition Scale: Berkshire Hathaway's $6.8 billion acquisition of Taylor Morrison, while driving a stock price increase, still reflects a relatively cheap valuation compared to peers, showcasing the company's strategic vision in the housing market.
- Management Style Shift: CEO Greg Abel's announcement of plans to unify Taylor Morrison's homebuilding operations into a single platform indicates a more hands-on management approach, contrasting sharply with Warren Buffett's laissez-faire style.
- Market Positioning: With a price-to-sales ratio of approximately 0.9x, Taylor Morrison is attractively priced compared to major homebuilders like D.R. Horton at 1.3x and PulteGroup at 1.4x, suggesting potential long-term value for Berkshire.
- Strategic Investment: Although the acquisition is substantial, at $6.8 billion, it is relatively small for Berkshire Hathaway's $1 trillion market cap, indicating a strategic, long-term investment rather than a bet on a short-term housing rebound.
See More
Toll Brothers Announces Peapack Crossing Luxury Home Community Launch
- Community Launch: Toll Brothers has announced the upcoming launch of Peapack Crossing luxury home community in Somerset County, New Jersey, anticipated to open for sale in summer 2026, marking the company's continued expansion in the high-end residential market.
- Diverse Home Offerings: Peapack Crossing will feature two distinct collections, including luxury carriage-style townhomes and single-family homes starting at $1.4 million, catering to various buyer preferences and further solidifying Toll Brothers' leadership in the luxury housing sector.
- Prime Location: The community is strategically located near highly ranked schools, outdoor recreational facilities, and major transit routes, providing residents easy access to New York City and Morristown, thereby enhancing the area's livability and appeal to affluent homebuyers.
- Enhanced Design Services: The Toll Brothers Design Studio offers homebuyers personalized selection options, supported by professional design consultants, enabling clients to customize their dream homes according to personal preferences, which enhances customer experience and brand loyalty.
See More
Toll Brothers Announces Final Luxury Home for Sale in Nevada
- Final Luxury Home: Toll Brothers has announced that only one luxury home remains for sale in the Venado Valley community in Carson City, Nevada, priced at $750,000, featuring 2,337 square feet, 4 bedrooms, and 3 bathrooms, appealing to buyers seeking upscale living.
- Community Features: The Venado Valley community consists of 40 single-family homes nestled in a private enclave at the edge of the Carson Range, offering a perfect blend of small-town charm and luxury living, attracting significant buyer interest.
- Convenient Location: Located less than 40 minutes from Lake Tahoe and just minutes from Carson City's historic downtown, the community provides easy access to shopping, dining, and outdoor recreation, enhancing the quality of life for residents.
- Industry Recognition: Toll Brothers was named the #1 Most Admired Home Builder in Fortune magazine's 2026 list of the World's Most Admired Companies®, marking the ninth consecutive year of this honor, further solidifying its leadership position in the luxury home market.
See More
Toll Brothers Announces Final Home Buying Opportunity
- Final Buying Opportunity: Toll Brothers announces that fewer than 15 luxury homes remain available at the Regency at Caramella Ranch community in South Reno, with prices starting from the upper $600,000s, attracting many buyers seeking a premium lifestyle.
- Community Features: The community offers luxury single-level home designs ranging from 1,680 to over 2,760 square feet, featuring 2 to 3 bedrooms and garages, catering to diverse family needs and enhancing living flexibility and comfort.
- Abundant Amenities: Regency at Caramella Ranch provides a resort-style lifestyle with amenities such as a large clubhouse, indoor lap pool, fitness center, and multi-tiered resort-style pool, significantly enhancing residents' social activities and quality of life.
- Strategic Location: Located within an hour of Lake Tahoe and close to golf courses and shopping centers, the community offers a convenient living environment while benefiting from no state income tax, drawing increased interest from potential homebuyers.
See More
Dow Industrials Hits New Record High Amid Market Movements
- Housing Market Trends: Toll Brothers has risen about 18% in the past month, despite a decline of 11% from February's peak, indicating volatility in the market and shifts in investor confidence.
- SpaceX Stock Performance: On its second day of trading, SpaceX gained nearly 20%, closing at $192.50 with a market cap of $2.5 trillion, reflecting strong market expectations for its future growth.
- Energy Market Review: West Texas Intermediate crude futures have dipped below $80, up over 20% since late February, yet the energy sector has declined 7.3% in the past month, highlighting market uncertainties.
- Market Indices New Highs: The Dow Industrials and NYSE Composite both hit new highs, rising nearly 11% and 7.3% over the past three months, respectively, showcasing robust overall market performance.
See More
Abel's First Acquisition: Taylor Morrison Purchase
- First Major Acquisition: Greg Abel, who took over as CEO in 2026, announced the $6.8 billion acquisition of Taylor Morrison on May 31, marking his first significant move, although market interpretations of this acquisition may be overstated.
- Market Reaction Analysis: The acquisition is not driven by expectations of a housing market rebound but rather by Taylor Morrison's relatively low valuation, with a current price-to-sales ratio of approximately 0.9x, compared to other major builders' ratios of 1.3x to 1.4x, indicating its attractiveness.
- Integration Strategy Intent: Abel explicitly stated in the announcement that he plans to unify Berkshire's homebuilding operations into a cohesive platform to better serve American homeowners, indicating a shift towards a more hands-on management approach.
- Long-Term Investment Perspective: While the $6.8 billion acquisition is relatively small for Berkshire's nearly $1 trillion market cap, considering its nearly $400 billion cash reserves, this move is more likely a strategic long-term investment rather than a bet on short-term market fluctuations.
See More
Berkshire Hathaway's Strategic Acquisition of Taylor Morrison
- Acquisition Scale: Berkshire Hathaway's $6.8 billion acquisition of Taylor Morrison, while driving a stock price increase, still reflects a relatively cheap valuation compared to peers, showcasing the company's strategic vision in the housing market.
- Management Style Shift: CEO Greg Abel's announcement of plans to unify Taylor Morrison's homebuilding operations into a single platform indicates a more hands-on management approach, contrasting sharply with Warren Buffett's laissez-faire style.
- Market Positioning: With a price-to-sales ratio of approximately 0.9x, Taylor Morrison is attractively priced compared to major homebuilders like D.R. Horton at 1.3x and PulteGroup at 1.4x, suggesting potential long-term value for Berkshire.
- Strategic Investment: Although the acquisition is substantial, at $6.8 billion, it is relatively small for Berkshire Hathaway's $1 trillion market cap, indicating a strategic, long-term investment rather than a bet on a short-term housing rebound.
See More
Toll Brothers Announces Peapack Crossing Luxury Home Community Launch
- Community Launch: Toll Brothers has announced the upcoming launch of Peapack Crossing luxury home community in Somerset County, New Jersey, anticipated to open for sale in summer 2026, marking the company's continued expansion in the high-end residential market.
- Diverse Home Offerings: Peapack Crossing will feature two distinct collections, including luxury carriage-style townhomes and single-family homes starting at $1.4 million, catering to various buyer preferences and further solidifying Toll Brothers' leadership in the luxury housing sector.
- Prime Location: The community is strategically located near highly ranked schools, outdoor recreational facilities, and major transit routes, providing residents easy access to New York City and Morristown, thereby enhancing the area's livability and appeal to affluent homebuyers.
- Enhanced Design Services: The Toll Brothers Design Studio offers homebuyers personalized selection options, supported by professional design consultants, enabling clients to customize their dream homes according to personal preferences, which enhances customer experience and brand loyalty.
See More
Toll Brothers Announces Final Luxury Home for Sale in Nevada
- Final Luxury Home: Toll Brothers has announced that only one luxury home remains for sale in the Venado Valley community in Carson City, Nevada, priced at $750,000, featuring 2,337 square feet, 4 bedrooms, and 3 bathrooms, appealing to buyers seeking upscale living.
- Community Features: The Venado Valley community consists of 40 single-family homes nestled in a private enclave at the edge of the Carson Range, offering a perfect blend of small-town charm and luxury living, attracting significant buyer interest.
- Convenient Location: Located less than 40 minutes from Lake Tahoe and just minutes from Carson City's historic downtown, the community provides easy access to shopping, dining, and outdoor recreation, enhancing the quality of life for residents.
- Industry Recognition: Toll Brothers was named the #1 Most Admired Home Builder in Fortune magazine's 2026 list of the World's Most Admired Companies®, marking the ninth consecutive year of this honor, further solidifying its leadership position in the luxury home market.
See More
