Reasons to Keep CarMax Stock in Your Portfolio at This Time
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Sep 26 2025
0mins
Should l Buy KMX?
Source: NASDAQ.COM
CarMax's Competitive Advantage: CarMax, the largest used vehicle retailer in the U.S., benefits from its extensive logistics network and strategic acquisitions, such as Edmunds, which enhance its digital capabilities and position in the used EV market.
Financial Concerns and Market Challenges: Despite its strengths, CarMax faces challenges from a stretched balance sheet, high long-term debt, and potential impacts from reciprocal tariffs, which could increase costs and reduce profit margins amid a competitive automotive retail landscape.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy KMX?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on KMX
Wall Street analysts forecast KMX stock price to fall
13 Analyst Rating
0 Buy
10 Hold
3 Sell
Hold
Current: 42.500
Low
24.00
Averages
33.60
High
37.00
Current: 42.500
Low
24.00
Averages
33.60
High
37.00
About KMX
CarMax, Inc. is a retailer of used autos. The Company operates through two segments: CarMax Sales Operations and CarMax Auto Finance (CAF). The CarMax Sales Operations segment consists of all aspects of its auto merchandising and service operations. The CarMax Sales Operations segment sells used vehicles, purchases used vehicles from customers and other sources, sells related products and services, and arranges financing options for customers. The CAF segment consists solely of its own finance operation that provides financing for customers buying retail vehicles from the Company. The CAF segment also services all auto loans, it originates and is responsible for providing billing statements, collecting payments, maintaining contact with delinquent customers, and arranging for the repossession of vehicles securing defaulted loans. It provides customers with a range of other related products and services, including extended protection plan (EPP) products and vehicle repair services.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Starboard Value Acquires $350 Million Stake in CarMax to Drive Turnaround
- Stake Acquisition: Starboard Value has acquired approximately $350 million in CarMax Inc (KMX), indicating confidence in the company's potential turnaround under incoming CEO Keith Barr, which could accelerate its recovery efforts.
- Board Nominations: As an activist investor, Starboard has nominated its CEO Jeff Smith and Frontdoor's chairman Bill Cobb to join the CarMax board, aiming to drive strategic changes and enhance governance through fresh leadership.
- Market Performance: Despite a 9% gain for CarMax so far in 2026, Seeking Alpha's Quant system remains cautious, assigning a 'Hold' rating, which reflects investor concerns regarding the company's valuation and competitive positioning.
- Technological Innovation: CarMax has launched a ChatGPT app to personalize the car shopping experience, aiming to enhance customer satisfaction and market competitiveness, although it faces skepticism regarding its competitive advantages.
See More
Starboard Nominates Directors to Drive CarMax Turnaround
- Board Nominations: Starboard has nominated Jeff Smith and Bill Cobb to CarMax's board, aiming to drive the company's turnaround under new CEO Keith Barr, enhancing performance amid competitive pressures.
- Shareholder Confidence: Following Starboard's announcement of a $350 million stake and board nominations, CarMax shares rose 4% in early trading on Wednesday, indicating a positive market sentiment towards the company's future.
- Strategic Change Proposals: Starboard's proposed changes include improving vehicle refurbishment efficiency, cutting over $300 million in administrative and overhead costs, and implementing dynamic pricing strategies to boost CarMax's competitiveness.
- Market Sentiment Shift: Despite a 42% decline in CarMax's stock over the past year compared to a 77% rise for rival Carvana, retail sentiment on Stocktwits has shifted from neutral to bullish, reflecting expectations for the company's turnaround efforts.
See More
Used Vehicle Price Index Rises 4%
- Index Increase: Cox Automotive reported a 4% year-over-year increase in the used vehicle price index for February 2026, reaching 212.3, which is up 0.8% from January 2023, indicating strong demand and an increase in dealer inventories.
- Sales Conversion Rates Rise: Jeremy Robb, Cox's chief economist, noted that since the beginning of 2026, sales conversion rates at Manheim have been solid, reflecting dealers' strong appetite for purchasing, particularly with prices rising unexpectedly in the latter half of February.
- Tax Refund Impact: Robb suggested that anticipated higher tax returns for American consumers could boost vehicle demand, although risks from the war in Iran may dampen consumer appetite in the short term, especially as gas prices rise.
- Historical Price Comparison: While used vehicle prices remain high compared to historical levels, the average listing price in January was $25,533, down from over $28,000 in 2022, yet still demonstrating market resilience, with expectations for wholesale prices to end 2% higher than December 2025.
See More
U.S. Oil Prices Surge, Market Eyes Jobs Data
- Oil Price Surge: U.S. oil futures have surged to their highest level since 2024, creating anticipation in the market that could impact overall economic sentiment and investor confidence.
- Jobs Data Expectations: The February payroll report is set to be released, with a consensus forecast of 50,000 new jobs, although some experts suggest a potential negative number, indicating a cautious outlook on economic recovery.
- Robinhood Stock Fluctuations: Robinhood's stock is down 47% from its October peak but has gained 67% over the past year, indicating a gradual recovery in investor confidence, further bolstered by positive comments from the CEO.
- Biotech Industry Challenges: The biotech ETF and related indices have declined by 6.2% and 11% respectively since January highs, reflecting pressures from recent FDA rejections, prompting investors to closely monitor market reactions.
See More
CarMax Under Investigation Following Poor Q2 Results
- Declining Financial Performance: CarMax's Q2 FY2026 results, announced on September 25, 2025, revealed a 5.4% drop in retail unit sales, a 6.3% decline in comparable store sales, and a 2.2% decrease in wholesale units, with net earnings per diluted share falling to $0.64 from $0.85 a year ago, indicating significant sales pressure and declining profitability.
- Significant Net Income Drop: The company's net income for the second quarter was approximately $95.4 million, down 28.1% from $132.8 million in the prior year, raising concerns among investors about the company's future profitability and potentially impacting stock performance.
- Executive Departure Impact: On November 6, 2025, CarMax unexpectedly announced the departure of its CEO and issued a weak preliminary outlook for Q3, which may further undermine market confidence in the company's management and lead to shareholder concerns regarding corporate governance.
- Securities Litigation Risk: CarMax and its executives are facing a class action lawsuit for failing to disclose material information as required by securities laws, with KSF investigating whether the company's officers breached their fiduciary duties to shareholders, potentially exposing the company to legal and financial risks.
See More
CarMax Launches AI-Powered Vehicle Shopping App
- App Innovation: CarMax's newly launched app features an AI-powered search engine that enhances the vehicle shopping experience, allowing customers to conduct more personalized searches based on their specific needs, which is expected to attract more user engagement.
- Competitive Edge: Similar to Carvana's 'Shaqbot', this app leverages generative AI technology combined with CarMax's inventory information to streamline the car buying and selling process, thereby enhancing customer satisfaction and market competitiveness.
- Market Reaction: Following the app's launch, CarMax shares turned positive on Friday, indicating a favorable response from investors towards the company's innovative initiatives, which may improve its market performance.
- Strategic Implications: By introducing this app, CarMax not only enhances its technological capabilities but also demonstrates its commitment to digital transformation, aiming to improve customer experience and drive future growth through technological innovation.
See More
Starboard Value Acquires $350 Million Stake in CarMax to Drive Turnaround
- Stake Acquisition: Starboard Value has acquired approximately $350 million in CarMax Inc (KMX), indicating confidence in the company's potential turnaround under incoming CEO Keith Barr, which could accelerate its recovery efforts.
- Board Nominations: As an activist investor, Starboard has nominated its CEO Jeff Smith and Frontdoor's chairman Bill Cobb to join the CarMax board, aiming to drive strategic changes and enhance governance through fresh leadership.
- Market Performance: Despite a 9% gain for CarMax so far in 2026, Seeking Alpha's Quant system remains cautious, assigning a 'Hold' rating, which reflects investor concerns regarding the company's valuation and competitive positioning.
- Technological Innovation: CarMax has launched a ChatGPT app to personalize the car shopping experience, aiming to enhance customer satisfaction and market competitiveness, although it faces skepticism regarding its competitive advantages.
See More
Starboard Nominates Directors to Drive CarMax Turnaround
- Board Nominations: Starboard has nominated Jeff Smith and Bill Cobb to CarMax's board, aiming to drive the company's turnaround under new CEO Keith Barr, enhancing performance amid competitive pressures.
- Shareholder Confidence: Following Starboard's announcement of a $350 million stake and board nominations, CarMax shares rose 4% in early trading on Wednesday, indicating a positive market sentiment towards the company's future.
- Strategic Change Proposals: Starboard's proposed changes include improving vehicle refurbishment efficiency, cutting over $300 million in administrative and overhead costs, and implementing dynamic pricing strategies to boost CarMax's competitiveness.
- Market Sentiment Shift: Despite a 42% decline in CarMax's stock over the past year compared to a 77% rise for rival Carvana, retail sentiment on Stocktwits has shifted from neutral to bullish, reflecting expectations for the company's turnaround efforts.
See More
Used Vehicle Price Index Rises 4%
- Index Increase: Cox Automotive reported a 4% year-over-year increase in the used vehicle price index for February 2026, reaching 212.3, which is up 0.8% from January 2023, indicating strong demand and an increase in dealer inventories.
- Sales Conversion Rates Rise: Jeremy Robb, Cox's chief economist, noted that since the beginning of 2026, sales conversion rates at Manheim have been solid, reflecting dealers' strong appetite for purchasing, particularly with prices rising unexpectedly in the latter half of February.
- Tax Refund Impact: Robb suggested that anticipated higher tax returns for American consumers could boost vehicle demand, although risks from the war in Iran may dampen consumer appetite in the short term, especially as gas prices rise.
- Historical Price Comparison: While used vehicle prices remain high compared to historical levels, the average listing price in January was $25,533, down from over $28,000 in 2022, yet still demonstrating market resilience, with expectations for wholesale prices to end 2% higher than December 2025.
See More
U.S. Oil Prices Surge, Market Eyes Jobs Data
- Oil Price Surge: U.S. oil futures have surged to their highest level since 2024, creating anticipation in the market that could impact overall economic sentiment and investor confidence.
- Jobs Data Expectations: The February payroll report is set to be released, with a consensus forecast of 50,000 new jobs, although some experts suggest a potential negative number, indicating a cautious outlook on economic recovery.
- Robinhood Stock Fluctuations: Robinhood's stock is down 47% from its October peak but has gained 67% over the past year, indicating a gradual recovery in investor confidence, further bolstered by positive comments from the CEO.
- Biotech Industry Challenges: The biotech ETF and related indices have declined by 6.2% and 11% respectively since January highs, reflecting pressures from recent FDA rejections, prompting investors to closely monitor market reactions.
See More
CarMax Under Investigation Following Poor Q2 Results
- Declining Financial Performance: CarMax's Q2 FY2026 results, announced on September 25, 2025, revealed a 5.4% drop in retail unit sales, a 6.3% decline in comparable store sales, and a 2.2% decrease in wholesale units, with net earnings per diluted share falling to $0.64 from $0.85 a year ago, indicating significant sales pressure and declining profitability.
- Significant Net Income Drop: The company's net income for the second quarter was approximately $95.4 million, down 28.1% from $132.8 million in the prior year, raising concerns among investors about the company's future profitability and potentially impacting stock performance.
- Executive Departure Impact: On November 6, 2025, CarMax unexpectedly announced the departure of its CEO and issued a weak preliminary outlook for Q3, which may further undermine market confidence in the company's management and lead to shareholder concerns regarding corporate governance.
- Securities Litigation Risk: CarMax and its executives are facing a class action lawsuit for failing to disclose material information as required by securities laws, with KSF investigating whether the company's officers breached their fiduciary duties to shareholders, potentially exposing the company to legal and financial risks.
See More
CarMax Launches AI-Powered Vehicle Shopping App
- App Innovation: CarMax's newly launched app features an AI-powered search engine that enhances the vehicle shopping experience, allowing customers to conduct more personalized searches based on their specific needs, which is expected to attract more user engagement.
- Competitive Edge: Similar to Carvana's 'Shaqbot', this app leverages generative AI technology combined with CarMax's inventory information to streamline the car buying and selling process, thereby enhancing customer satisfaction and market competitiveness.
- Market Reaction: Following the app's launch, CarMax shares turned positive on Friday, indicating a favorable response from investors towards the company's innovative initiatives, which may improve its market performance.
- Strategic Implications: By introducing this app, CarMax not only enhances its technological capabilities but also demonstrates its commitment to digital transformation, aiming to improve customer experience and drive future growth through technological innovation.
See More
