Based on the provided data and recent analyst updates, here's a concise analysis of KMX's valuation:
KMX is currently trading at $85.45, showing mixed valuation signals. The stock's P/E ratio has increased from 26.16 to 28.53 over recent quarters, suggesting slightly elevated valuation levels compared to historical trends. However, several factors indicate the stock may not be overvalued:
Recent analyst upgrades support this view - Evercore ISI upgraded KMX to Outperform with a $110 price target, representing nearly 29% upside potential. Needham also raised their price target to $101, citing improved used auto market dynamics and CarMax's unit gains.
The company demonstrated strong operational performance in Q3, with retail used vehicle sales increasing 5.4% year-over-year. This growth trajectory, combined with stable vehicle valuations and improved Auto Finance income, suggests the current valuation multiple may be justified.
While trading above some analysts' average price target of $84.57, the stock remains approximately 10% below its 52-week high of $91.25, indicating potential room for upward movement based on improving industry fundamentals and company-specific execution.