Hagerty Releases 2026 Bull Market List Highlighting 11 Cars Expected to Appreciate
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Dec 08 2025
0mins
Should l Buy HGTY?
Source: Newsfilter
- Appreciation Potential: Hagerty's 2026 Bull Market List features 11 cars expected to appreciate in value over the next year, ranging from under $10,000 to over $1 million, highlighting strong market interest in both classic and modern vehicles.
- Trend Among Young Buyers: The BMW M5 sees 58% of interest from enthusiasts under 40, indicating a rising preference for high-performance models among younger consumers, which could drive future sales growth.
- Market Analysis Methodology: Hagerty identifies these investment-worthy vehicles by analyzing millions of data points, including public auction results and insurance valuations, showcasing its expertise and foresight in the automotive market.
- Insurance Value Growth: Since 2021, Hagerty's average insured value has increased by 57%, reflecting a robust recovery in the collector car market and sustained consumer demand for high-value automobiles.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy HGTY?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on HGTY
Wall Street analysts forecast HGTY stock price to rise
4 Analyst Rating
1 Buy
3 Hold
0 Sell
Hold
Current: 10.660
Low
11.00
Averages
13.50
High
15.00
Current: 10.660
Low
11.00
Averages
13.50
High
15.00
About HGTY
Hagerty, Inc. is an automotive enthusiast brand. The Company is a provider of specialty vehicle insurance, expert car valuation data and insights, live and digital car auction services, immersive events and automotive entertainment custom made for the Americans who self-describe as car enthusiasts. Through its insurance business, the Company acts as a Managing General Agent (MGA) by underwriting, selling, and servicing collector car and enthusiast vehicle insurance policies. In addition, the Company offers Hagerty Drivers Club (HDC) memberships, which are primarily bundled with its insurance policies and give subscribers access to an array of products and services, including emergency roadside assistance, Hagerty Drivers Club Magazine, automotive enthusiast events, its proprietary vehicle valuation tool, and special vehicle-related discounts. It provides insurance for approximately 2.6 million collector cars and enthusiast vehicles.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Ferrari Monza SP2 to be Featured at Auction
- Rare Model Auction: Broad Arrow Auctions will feature a low-mileage Ferrari Monza SP2 at the Concorso d'Eleganza Villa d'Este Auction on May 16-17, 2026, a highly coveted Icona series car expected to generate intense bidding among international collectors.
- Powerful Performance: The Monza SP2 is equipped with a 6.5-liter naturally aspirated V12 engine, delivering 798 horsepower and 719 Nm of torque, achieving 0-100 km/h in just 2.9 seconds, showcasing Ferrari's engineering prowess.
- Unique Design: This model features a carbon fiber body and an innovative 'Virtual Windshield' design that optimizes aerodynamics, enhancing speed and downforce, ensuring an unparalleled driving experience suitable for legendary events like the Mille Miglia.
- Collectible Value: Offered exclusively to discerning Ferrari clients, the Monza SP2, with its Tailor Made paintwork and extensive options, stands as one of the most collectible Ferraris of the 21st century, drawing significant attention from enthusiasts.
See More
BROAD ARROW OFFERS UNIQUE CHANCE TO PURCHASE FERRARI MONZA SP2 AT CONCORSO D’ELEGANZA VILLA D’ESTE AUCTION
- Rare Opportunity: Broad Arrow presents a unique chance to acquire a Ferrari Monza SP2 at the Concours d'Elegance Villa d'Este.
- Event Details: The auction will take place at a prestigious event known for showcasing classic and luxury automobiles.
See More
Record Auction Sales at The Amelia Concours
- Record Auction Sales: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved over $111 million in sales at the Amelia Concours, with 92% of lots sold, marking the highest sales record in the event's 31-year history, reflecting robust demand and investment potential in the collector car market.
- Best of Show Awards: The 1931 Duesenberg Model J and the 1969 McLaren M8B were awarded Best of Show and Best of Sport respectively, with the former's unique design and historical significance captivating enthusiasts, while the latter's dominance in the 1969 Can-Am season highlighted its racing pedigree.
- Increased Participation: The event attracted over 1,000 registered bidders from 23 countries, creating a vibrant atmosphere that underscores the global interest and engagement in high-end automotive culture, further enhancing brand visibility and influence.
- Future Outlook: The Amelia Concours will return from March 4-7, 2027, and Hagerty plans to host the Greenwich Concours on May 30-31, 2026, aiming to continuously engage automotive enthusiasts and solidify its pivotal role in automotive culture.
See More
Amelia Concours Achieves Historic Success
- Record Auction Sales: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved a historic total of $111 million during the Amelia Concours, marking the highest sales in the event's 31-year history, reflecting strong demand and enthusiasm in the collector car market.
- Best in Show Awards: The 1931 Duesenberg Model J and the 1969 McLaren M8B were awarded Best of Show and Best of Sport respectively, with the former's unique design and historical significance captivating enthusiasts, while the latter's dominance in the 1969 Can-Am season garnered significant attention.
- High Participant Engagement: The event attracted over 1,000 registered bidders from 23 countries, resulting in standing-room-only conditions at the auction, showcasing the global interest and engagement of automotive enthusiasts in high-end vehicles.
- Future Event Announcements: Hagerty announced the upcoming Greenwich Concours on May 30-31, 2026, and the opening night of Monterey Car Week on August 12, further solidifying its prominent role in automotive culture.
See More
2026 Amelia Concours Auction Sets Record with Over $111 Million in Sales
- Total Sales Record: The 2026 Amelia Concours Auction held at The Ritz-Carlton in Florida achieved over $111 million in total sales with 92% of lots sold, marking the highest grossing auction in the 31-year history of Amelia, indicating robust demand in the collector car market.
- Supercar Demand Surge: The auction saw particularly strong demand for modern supercars, especially from a private collection, leading to multiple world record prices, with the 2003 Ferrari Enzo selling for $15,185,000, highlighting the vibrancy of the high-end market.
- World Record Count: A total of 13 new world records were set during the auction, including the 2005 Porsche Carrera GT and the 1972 Lamborghini Miura P400 SV, which sold for $6,715,000 and $6,605,000 respectively, reflecting the increasing investment value of various collectible cars.
- Future Auction Plans: Broad Arrow Auctions is set to host the Air|Water auction on April 25, 2026, featuring over 60 desirable Porsches and memorabilia, further solidifying its leadership position in the global collector car auction market.
See More
Broad Arrow Auctions Sets Record Sales at Amelia Concours
- Record Auction Total: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved over $107 million in total sales at the 2026 Amelia Concours Auction, marking its most successful auction since its inception in 2021, highlighting strong demand and investment potential in the collector car market.
- Miura Auction Record: The 1972 Lamborghini Miura P400 SV sold for $6,605,000, exceeding its estimated range of $3.5-4 million, becoming the highest-selling Miura at auction, reflecting the ongoing enthusiasm and collectible value in the high-end automotive market.
- Multiple World Records: The auction also set new records for the 2001 RUF RGT and the 2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale, which sold for $335,000 and $912,500 respectively, further demonstrating the market appeal and investment returns of modern collectible cars.
- Market Trend Insights: The auction attracted passionate collectors and featured a diverse range of vehicles from the 1990s to 2000s, alongside pre- and post-war American and European classics, indicating a diversification in the collector market and investors' preference for high-quality assets.
See More
Ferrari Monza SP2 to be Featured at Auction
- Rare Model Auction: Broad Arrow Auctions will feature a low-mileage Ferrari Monza SP2 at the Concorso d'Eleganza Villa d'Este Auction on May 16-17, 2026, a highly coveted Icona series car expected to generate intense bidding among international collectors.
- Powerful Performance: The Monza SP2 is equipped with a 6.5-liter naturally aspirated V12 engine, delivering 798 horsepower and 719 Nm of torque, achieving 0-100 km/h in just 2.9 seconds, showcasing Ferrari's engineering prowess.
- Unique Design: This model features a carbon fiber body and an innovative 'Virtual Windshield' design that optimizes aerodynamics, enhancing speed and downforce, ensuring an unparalleled driving experience suitable for legendary events like the Mille Miglia.
- Collectible Value: Offered exclusively to discerning Ferrari clients, the Monza SP2, with its Tailor Made paintwork and extensive options, stands as one of the most collectible Ferraris of the 21st century, drawing significant attention from enthusiasts.
See More
BROAD ARROW OFFERS UNIQUE CHANCE TO PURCHASE FERRARI MONZA SP2 AT CONCORSO D’ELEGANZA VILLA D’ESTE AUCTION
- Rare Opportunity: Broad Arrow presents a unique chance to acquire a Ferrari Monza SP2 at the Concours d'Elegance Villa d'Este.
- Event Details: The auction will take place at a prestigious event known for showcasing classic and luxury automobiles.
See More
Record Auction Sales at The Amelia Concours
- Record Auction Sales: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved over $111 million in sales at the Amelia Concours, with 92% of lots sold, marking the highest sales record in the event's 31-year history, reflecting robust demand and investment potential in the collector car market.
- Best of Show Awards: The 1931 Duesenberg Model J and the 1969 McLaren M8B were awarded Best of Show and Best of Sport respectively, with the former's unique design and historical significance captivating enthusiasts, while the latter's dominance in the 1969 Can-Am season highlighted its racing pedigree.
- Increased Participation: The event attracted over 1,000 registered bidders from 23 countries, creating a vibrant atmosphere that underscores the global interest and engagement in high-end automotive culture, further enhancing brand visibility and influence.
- Future Outlook: The Amelia Concours will return from March 4-7, 2027, and Hagerty plans to host the Greenwich Concours on May 30-31, 2026, aiming to continuously engage automotive enthusiasts and solidify its pivotal role in automotive culture.
See More
Amelia Concours Achieves Historic Success
- Record Auction Sales: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved a historic total of $111 million during the Amelia Concours, marking the highest sales in the event's 31-year history, reflecting strong demand and enthusiasm in the collector car market.
- Best in Show Awards: The 1931 Duesenberg Model J and the 1969 McLaren M8B were awarded Best of Show and Best of Sport respectively, with the former's unique design and historical significance captivating enthusiasts, while the latter's dominance in the 1969 Can-Am season garnered significant attention.
- High Participant Engagement: The event attracted over 1,000 registered bidders from 23 countries, resulting in standing-room-only conditions at the auction, showcasing the global interest and engagement of automotive enthusiasts in high-end vehicles.
- Future Event Announcements: Hagerty announced the upcoming Greenwich Concours on May 30-31, 2026, and the opening night of Monterey Car Week on August 12, further solidifying its prominent role in automotive culture.
See More
2026 Amelia Concours Auction Sets Record with Over $111 Million in Sales
- Total Sales Record: The 2026 Amelia Concours Auction held at The Ritz-Carlton in Florida achieved over $111 million in total sales with 92% of lots sold, marking the highest grossing auction in the 31-year history of Amelia, indicating robust demand in the collector car market.
- Supercar Demand Surge: The auction saw particularly strong demand for modern supercars, especially from a private collection, leading to multiple world record prices, with the 2003 Ferrari Enzo selling for $15,185,000, highlighting the vibrancy of the high-end market.
- World Record Count: A total of 13 new world records were set during the auction, including the 2005 Porsche Carrera GT and the 1972 Lamborghini Miura P400 SV, which sold for $6,715,000 and $6,605,000 respectively, reflecting the increasing investment value of various collectible cars.
- Future Auction Plans: Broad Arrow Auctions is set to host the Air|Water auction on April 25, 2026, featuring over 60 desirable Porsches and memorabilia, further solidifying its leadership position in the global collector car auction market.
See More
Broad Arrow Auctions Sets Record Sales at Amelia Concours
- Record Auction Total: Broad Arrow Auctions achieved over $107 million in total sales at the 2026 Amelia Concours Auction, marking its most successful auction since its inception in 2021, highlighting strong demand and investment potential in the collector car market.
- Miura Auction Record: The 1972 Lamborghini Miura P400 SV sold for $6,605,000, exceeding its estimated range of $3.5-4 million, becoming the highest-selling Miura at auction, reflecting the ongoing enthusiasm and collectible value in the high-end automotive market.
- Multiple World Records: The auction also set new records for the 2001 RUF RGT and the 2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale, which sold for $335,000 and $912,500 respectively, further demonstrating the market appeal and investment returns of modern collectible cars.
- Market Trend Insights: The auction attracted passionate collectors and featured a diverse range of vehicles from the 1990s to 2000s, alongside pre- and post-war American and European classics, indicating a diversification in the collector market and investors' preference for high-quality assets.
See More
