Comparative Analysis of Silver ETFs: SLV vs SLVP
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Jan 26 2026
0mins
Should l Buy HL?
Source: Fool
- Investment Strategy Differences: The iShares MSCI Global Silver ETF (SLVP) holds shares of global mining companies tied to silver and other metals, while the iShares Silver Trust (SLV) aims to directly track the price of physical silver, catering to different investor needs.
- Cost and Return Comparison: SLVP has an expense ratio of 0.39% with a 1-year return of 265.8%, while SLV has a 0.50% expense ratio and a return of 231.23%, demonstrating SLVP's advantage in cost-effectiveness and returns.
- Risk and Volatility Analysis: SLVP's maximum drawdown is -55.56%, compared to SLV's -38.79%, indicating that while SLV is less volatile, the inherent volatility of silver prices remains a critical consideration for investors.
- Market Demand and Supply Challenges: As demand for silver increases in sectors like electric vehicles and solar panels, its scarcity is expected to drive prices up, but silver mining companies may need to adjust operational strategies, potentially impacting SLVP's performance.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy HL?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on HL
Wall Street analysts forecast HL stock price to rise
7 Analyst Rating
2 Buy
4 Hold
1 Sell
Hold
Current: 19.180
Low
16.00
Averages
23.93
High
36.50
Current: 19.180
Low
16.00
Averages
23.93
High
36.50
About HL
Hecla Mining Company is a silver producer in the United States and Canada. The Company discovers, acquires and develops mines and other mineral interests and produces and markets concentrates containing silver, gold, lead, zinc and copper; carbon material containing silver and gold, and unrefined dore containing silver and gold. The Company's segments include Greens Creek, Lucky Friday, Keno Hill and Casa Berardi. The Greens Creek operation is located on Admiralty Island, near Juneau, Alaska. The Greens Creek ore body contains silver, zinc, gold and lead. The Lucky Friday mine is a deep underground silver, lead, and zinc mine located in the Coeur d’Alene Mining District in northern Idaho. The Casa Berardi mine is an underground/open-pit gold mine located in western Quebec. It owns 100% of the Keno Hill Silver Project, which is located within the Keno Hill Silver District in Canada’s Yukon Territory. The Company also owns a number of exploration and pre-development projects.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
US Stocks Plummet as Oil Prices Surge
- Oil Price Surge: Crude oil prices soared over 13% as President Trump took a tougher stance on Iran, reaching a 3.5-week high, which not only heightened inflation fears but also pushed bond yields higher, with the 10-year T-note yield rising by 2 basis points to 4.34%.
- Unemployment Claims Drop: Weekly initial unemployment claims unexpectedly fell by 9,000 to 202,000, indicating a stronger labor market than the anticipated increase to 212,000, which could provide support for the stock market amid rising inflation concerns.
- Global Market Decline: Overseas stock markets are lower, with the Euro Stoxx 50 down 2.25%, China's Shanghai Composite down 0.74%, and Japan's Nikkei 225 sharply falling 2.38% from a two-week high, reflecting global economic uncertainty and investor caution.
- Airline Stocks Plummet: Airline stocks are sharply lower as crude oil prices surged over 10%, raising fuel costs; United Airlines and American Airlines Group both fell more than 6%, highlighting the direct impact of rising oil prices on airline profitability.
See More
US Stocks Close Higher Amid Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Rally: The S&P 500 rose by 0.72%, the Dow Jones increased by 0.48%, and the Nasdaq 100 climbed by 1.18%, reflecting growing investor optimism regarding a potential resolution to the Middle East conflict, which has bolstered market confidence.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, indicating robust economic recovery that could influence Federal Reserve policy decisions.
- Interest Rate Expectations: Despite positive economic indicators, hawkish comments from St. Louis Fed President raised concerns about inflation and employment, leading to a mere 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming April FOMC meeting, reflecting cautious market sentiment.
- Divergent Stock Performances: Target Hospitality surged over 36% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while Nike fell more than 15% due to revenue forecasts indicating a decline, highlighting the market's varied outlook on different companies' futures.
See More
US Stocks Rise on Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Rally: The S&P 500 Index rose by 0.97%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average by 0.86%, and the Nasdaq 100 by 1.45%, reflecting growing investor confidence amid optimism that the Middle East conflict may soon conclude, which could stabilize global markets.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, indicating robust economic recovery that may influence Federal Reserve policy decisions.
- Interest Rate Outlook: Despite a mere 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting, hawkish comments from St. Louis Fed President raised concerns about inflation and employment risks, potentially affecting investor sentiment and market dynamics.
- Divergent Stock Performances: Target Hospitality surged by over 37% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while Nike fell by more than 13% due to revenue forecasts indicating a decline, highlighting varied market reactions to company-specific news.
See More
US Stocks Rise on Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Optimism: The S&P 500 index rose by 0.52%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average by 0.43%, and the Nasdaq 100 by 0.68%, reflecting investor optimism regarding a potential resolution to the Middle East conflict, which has fueled a continuation of Tuesday's strong rally.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, exceeding the anticipated 0.5%, bolstering market confidence in economic recovery and potentially influencing future monetary policy.
- Interest Rate Expectations: Despite hawkish comments from the St. Louis Fed President putting pressure on stocks, the market is still pricing in only a 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting on April 28-29, indicating a cautious optimism regarding economic growth.
- Notable Stock Performances: Target Hospitality's stock surged over 28% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while nCino's forecast of $569 million to $573 million in subscription revenue for 2027 exceeded market expectations, highlighting strong demand in the tech and service sectors.
See More
Gulf War Triggers Sharp Sell-off in Gold and Silver
- Investor Shock: The outbreak of the Gulf War has led to a sharp sell-off in gold and silver, which are typically seen as safe-haven assets; this recent decline reflects market panic over the conflict, shaking investor confidence.
- Significant Demand Changes: According to the IMF, investors held 2.8% of their assets in gold in 2025, double the figure from a decade ago, while investment demand for gold increased by nearly 990 tonnes compared to 2024, indicating strong long-term demand despite short-term price volatility.
- Stable Industrial Demand: Industrial demand for silver accounts for 59% of total demand and remained stable in 2025 compared to 2024, with expectations that increased usage in new data centers will further drive silver demand, highlighting its importance in emerging technologies.
- Central Bank Buying Potential: Although central bank demand for gold declined in 2025, this may align with banks reaching their target holdings due to price increases; any significant drop in gold prices could trigger increased buying from central banks, reflecting ongoing concerns over U.S. debt levels and geopolitical tensions.
See More
Gold and Silver Decline Short-Term but Long-Term Outlook Remains Positive
- Safe-Haven Performance Decline: Despite being regarded as safe-haven assets, both gold and silver have seen significant declines following the onset of the Persian Gulf war, reflecting a market reaction to conflict that has undermined investor confidence in these traditional safe assets.
- Investment Demand Growth: According to the World Gold Council, investment demand for gold increased by nearly 990 tonnes in 2025 compared to 2024, while silver saw an increase of 13.5 million ounces, indicating that despite short-term price volatility, long-term demand remains robust, particularly supported by central banks and industrial sectors.
- Rising Central Bank Holdings: The International Monetary Fund reports that the share of gold in global official reserves has risen from 6% during the 2008 financial crisis to nearly 13% by the end of 2024, highlighting growing concerns about counterparty risk associated with U.S. Treasuries, which is driving long-term demand for gold.
- Future Potential Emergence: Although marginal demand from central banks declined in 2025, this may align with banks reaching their target gold holdings, suggesting that any significant price drop could trigger increased central bank buying, especially given the ongoing concerns over U.S. debt levels and geopolitical tensions.
See More
US Stocks Plummet as Oil Prices Surge
- Oil Price Surge: Crude oil prices soared over 13% as President Trump took a tougher stance on Iran, reaching a 3.5-week high, which not only heightened inflation fears but also pushed bond yields higher, with the 10-year T-note yield rising by 2 basis points to 4.34%.
- Unemployment Claims Drop: Weekly initial unemployment claims unexpectedly fell by 9,000 to 202,000, indicating a stronger labor market than the anticipated increase to 212,000, which could provide support for the stock market amid rising inflation concerns.
- Global Market Decline: Overseas stock markets are lower, with the Euro Stoxx 50 down 2.25%, China's Shanghai Composite down 0.74%, and Japan's Nikkei 225 sharply falling 2.38% from a two-week high, reflecting global economic uncertainty and investor caution.
- Airline Stocks Plummet: Airline stocks are sharply lower as crude oil prices surged over 10%, raising fuel costs; United Airlines and American Airlines Group both fell more than 6%, highlighting the direct impact of rising oil prices on airline profitability.
See More
US Stocks Close Higher Amid Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Rally: The S&P 500 rose by 0.72%, the Dow Jones increased by 0.48%, and the Nasdaq 100 climbed by 1.18%, reflecting growing investor optimism regarding a potential resolution to the Middle East conflict, which has bolstered market confidence.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, indicating robust economic recovery that could influence Federal Reserve policy decisions.
- Interest Rate Expectations: Despite positive economic indicators, hawkish comments from St. Louis Fed President raised concerns about inflation and employment, leading to a mere 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming April FOMC meeting, reflecting cautious market sentiment.
- Divergent Stock Performances: Target Hospitality surged over 36% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while Nike fell more than 15% due to revenue forecasts indicating a decline, highlighting the market's varied outlook on different companies' futures.
See More
US Stocks Rise on Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Rally: The S&P 500 Index rose by 0.97%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average by 0.86%, and the Nasdaq 100 by 1.45%, reflecting growing investor confidence amid optimism that the Middle East conflict may soon conclude, which could stabilize global markets.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, indicating robust economic recovery that may influence Federal Reserve policy decisions.
- Interest Rate Outlook: Despite a mere 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting, hawkish comments from St. Louis Fed President raised concerns about inflation and employment risks, potentially affecting investor sentiment and market dynamics.
- Divergent Stock Performances: Target Hospitality surged by over 37% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while Nike fell by more than 13% due to revenue forecasts indicating a decline, highlighting varied market reactions to company-specific news.
See More
US Stocks Rise on Optimism Over Middle East Conflict Resolution
- Market Optimism: The S&P 500 index rose by 0.52%, the Dow Jones Industrial Average by 0.43%, and the Nasdaq 100 by 0.68%, reflecting investor optimism regarding a potential resolution to the Middle East conflict, which has fueled a continuation of Tuesday's strong rally.
- Strong Economic Data: The US ADP employment change for March increased by 62,000, surpassing expectations of 40,000, while February retail sales rose by 0.6% month-over-month, exceeding the anticipated 0.5%, bolstering market confidence in economic recovery and potentially influencing future monetary policy.
- Interest Rate Expectations: Despite hawkish comments from the St. Louis Fed President putting pressure on stocks, the market is still pricing in only a 1% chance of a 25 basis point rate hike at the upcoming FOMC meeting on April 28-29, indicating a cautious optimism regarding economic growth.
- Notable Stock Performances: Target Hospitality's stock surged over 28% after securing a multi-year contract worth over $550 million, while nCino's forecast of $569 million to $573 million in subscription revenue for 2027 exceeded market expectations, highlighting strong demand in the tech and service sectors.
See More
Gulf War Triggers Sharp Sell-off in Gold and Silver
- Investor Shock: The outbreak of the Gulf War has led to a sharp sell-off in gold and silver, which are typically seen as safe-haven assets; this recent decline reflects market panic over the conflict, shaking investor confidence.
- Significant Demand Changes: According to the IMF, investors held 2.8% of their assets in gold in 2025, double the figure from a decade ago, while investment demand for gold increased by nearly 990 tonnes compared to 2024, indicating strong long-term demand despite short-term price volatility.
- Stable Industrial Demand: Industrial demand for silver accounts for 59% of total demand and remained stable in 2025 compared to 2024, with expectations that increased usage in new data centers will further drive silver demand, highlighting its importance in emerging technologies.
- Central Bank Buying Potential: Although central bank demand for gold declined in 2025, this may align with banks reaching their target holdings due to price increases; any significant drop in gold prices could trigger increased buying from central banks, reflecting ongoing concerns over U.S. debt levels and geopolitical tensions.
See More
Gold and Silver Decline Short-Term but Long-Term Outlook Remains Positive
- Safe-Haven Performance Decline: Despite being regarded as safe-haven assets, both gold and silver have seen significant declines following the onset of the Persian Gulf war, reflecting a market reaction to conflict that has undermined investor confidence in these traditional safe assets.
- Investment Demand Growth: According to the World Gold Council, investment demand for gold increased by nearly 990 tonnes in 2025 compared to 2024, while silver saw an increase of 13.5 million ounces, indicating that despite short-term price volatility, long-term demand remains robust, particularly supported by central banks and industrial sectors.
- Rising Central Bank Holdings: The International Monetary Fund reports that the share of gold in global official reserves has risen from 6% during the 2008 financial crisis to nearly 13% by the end of 2024, highlighting growing concerns about counterparty risk associated with U.S. Treasuries, which is driving long-term demand for gold.
- Future Potential Emergence: Although marginal demand from central banks declined in 2025, this may align with banks reaching their target gold holdings, suggesting that any significant price drop could trigger increased central bank buying, especially given the ongoing concerns over U.S. debt levels and geopolitical tensions.
See More
