Comparing Dividends: Walmart vs. Macy's
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: 3 days ago
0mins
Source: Fool
- Walmart's Profitability: In the fiscal third quarter ending October 31, Walmart's adjusted operating profit grew 8% year-over-year to $7.2 billion, demonstrating its strong profitability that supports ongoing dividend payments, having raised dividends for over 50 consecutive years, earning the title of Dividend King.
- Macy's Turnaround Plan: Macy's reported a 3.4% increase in same-store sales for Q3 2023, indicating early success in its turnaround strategy; despite challenges, its 3.2% dividend yield attracts income-seeking investors.
- Free Cash Flow Comparison: Walmart generated $8.8 billion in free cash flow over the past nine months, significantly exceeding its $5.6 billion dividend payout, indicating financial strength; in contrast, Macy's free cash flow was $545.7 million, sufficient to cover its $200 million dividend payout, but still requires caution.
- Investment Risk Assessment: While Macy's higher dividend yield is appealing, the uncertainties in its turnaround process suggest that risk-averse investors should be cautious, whereas Walmart's stable earnings and history of dividend growth make it suitable for long-term investors.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy WMT?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on WMT
Wall Street analysts forecast WMT stock price to fall
26 Analyst Rating
25 Buy
1 Hold
0 Sell
Strong Buy
Current: 133.640
Low
119.00
Averages
125.75
High
136.00
Current: 133.640
Low
119.00
Averages
125.75
High
136.00
About WMT
Walmart Inc. is a technology-powered omnichannel retailer. The Company is engaged in the operation of retail and wholesale stores and clubs, as well as eCommerce Websites and mobile applications, located throughout the United States (U.S.), Africa, Canada, Central America, Chile, China, India and Mexico. It operates in three reportable segments: Walmart U.S., Walmart International and Sam's Club U.S. The Walmart U.S. segment includes the Company's mass merchandising concept in the U.S., as well as eCommerce, which includes omni-channel initiatives and certain other business offerings such as advertising services. The Walmart International segment consists of the Company's operations outside of the U.S. through its subsidiaries, as well as eCommerce and omni-channel initiatives. The Sam's Club U.S. segment includes the warehouse membership clubs in the U.S., as well as samsclub.com and omni-channel initiatives.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Walmart Investors Should Exercise Caution Ahead of Earnings Report
- Strong Stock Performance: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% year-to-date, reaching a split-adjusted all-time high, and has gained nearly 29% over the past 12 months, reflecting robust market performance and investor confidence.
- Analyst Upgrades: Several analysts have raised Walmart's price targets, with Oppenheimer expecting fourth-quarter holiday sales to come in at the high end of Walmart's projected growth range, further boosting the stock price.
- Market Share Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income shoppers by enhancing online and in-store pickup services, modernizing stores, and broadening brand selections, thereby increasing its competitive edge and encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks Emerge: Despite Walmart reaching a $1 trillion market cap, making it the 12th company to do so, its price-to-earnings ratio stands at 45, indicating potential overvaluation, prompting investors to carefully consider their buying timing.
See More
Overview of U.S. Markets Closure on Presidents' Day
- Market Closure: The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are closed today in observance of Presidents' Day, with U.S. bond markets also fully shut down, indicating the holiday's direct impact on financial operations, with trading resuming on February 17.
- Banking Services: Most commercial banks, including JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, and Capital One, are closed today following the Federal Reserve's holiday schedule, although online banking and ATM services remain operational, with transactions likely delayed until the next business day.
- Postal Service Suspension: The U.S. Postal Service has suspended regular mail delivery and closed all retail post office locations today, while private carriers continue to operate, highlighting the operational differences in public services during holidays.
- Retail Promotions: Many department stores are leveraging Presidents' Day for significant sales, particularly in furniture and appliances, aiming to attract consumers and boost sales, reflecting retailers' strategic approaches during holiday periods.
See More
Amazon: The Smartest Growth Stock to Buy Now
- Attractive Valuation: Amazon's stock is currently trading at about 26.5 times the 2026 expected P/E ratio, significantly lower than valuations of traditional retailers like Walmart and Costco, making it one of the cheapest investment opportunities in its history and attracting investor interest.
- Operational Efficiency Gains: With over 1 million robots deployed in its distribution centers and coordinated by the DeepFleet AI model, Amazon has not only increased delivery speed but also significantly enhanced operational efficiency, driving sales growth.
- Advertising Revenue Surge: Amazon's high-margin sponsored ad business saw a 22% revenue increase last quarter, becoming a key driver of its operating income growth and further solidifying its leading position in the global digital advertising space.
- Cloud Computing Market Leadership: Holding the number one market share in cloud computing, Amazon's revenue growth reached 24% in Q4, the highest in over three years, indicating its commitment to invest $200 billion in capital expenditures to meet the booming demand for AI infrastructure.
See More
Walmart Investors Should Exercise Caution Ahead of Earnings Report
- Strong Stock Performance: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% year-to-date, reaching an adjusted all-time high, and has gained nearly 29% over the past 12 months, indicating robust market performance that attracts investor interest.
- Analyst Optimism: Analysts at Oppenheimer expect Walmart's fourth-quarter holiday sales to come in at the high end of the projected growth range of 3.75% to 4.75%, reflecting market confidence in its sales performance, which could further boost the stock price.
- Market Share Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income consumers through modernized stores and online pickup services, enhancing its position in the competitive retail market and encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks Emerge: Despite Walmart reaching a $1 trillion market cap, its price-to-earnings ratio stands at 45, the highest since 2021, indicating that the stock may be overvalued, prompting investors to carefully consider their buying timing.
See More
Walmart Stock Soars to All-Time High
- Stock Surge: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% this year, reaching an all-time high and surpassing a $1 trillion market cap, making it the 12th company to achieve this milestone, indicating strong performance in the retail sector.
- Analyst Upgrades: Several analysts have raised Walmart's price targets, with Oppenheimer expecting fourth-quarter holiday sales to hit the high end of the projected growth range of 3.75% to 4.75%, reflecting market optimism about its sales outlook.
- Customer Base Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income shoppers while maintaining its traditional budget-conscious clientele, enhancing its market competitiveness through modernized stores and online pickup services, thereby encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks: Despite Walmart's strong performance, its price-to-earnings ratio has reached 45 times, the highest since 2021, prompting analysts to advise caution for investors considering purchases, as profit-taking may occur post-earnings report.
See More
Key Companies to Monitor This Week: PCE, Walmart, Palo Alto, Analog Devices, Deere, and Others
- Market Performance: Equities experienced a decline last week, with all three major indexes falling by at least 1.2%.
- Economic Indicators: This downturn occurred despite a better-than-expected jobs report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and a relatively stable inflation report.
See More
Walmart Investors Should Exercise Caution Ahead of Earnings Report
- Strong Stock Performance: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% year-to-date, reaching a split-adjusted all-time high, and has gained nearly 29% over the past 12 months, reflecting robust market performance and investor confidence.
- Analyst Upgrades: Several analysts have raised Walmart's price targets, with Oppenheimer expecting fourth-quarter holiday sales to come in at the high end of Walmart's projected growth range, further boosting the stock price.
- Market Share Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income shoppers by enhancing online and in-store pickup services, modernizing stores, and broadening brand selections, thereby increasing its competitive edge and encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks Emerge: Despite Walmart reaching a $1 trillion market cap, making it the 12th company to do so, its price-to-earnings ratio stands at 45, indicating potential overvaluation, prompting investors to carefully consider their buying timing.
See More
Overview of U.S. Markets Closure on Presidents' Day
- Market Closure: The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are closed today in observance of Presidents' Day, with U.S. bond markets also fully shut down, indicating the holiday's direct impact on financial operations, with trading resuming on February 17.
- Banking Services: Most commercial banks, including JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, and Capital One, are closed today following the Federal Reserve's holiday schedule, although online banking and ATM services remain operational, with transactions likely delayed until the next business day.
- Postal Service Suspension: The U.S. Postal Service has suspended regular mail delivery and closed all retail post office locations today, while private carriers continue to operate, highlighting the operational differences in public services during holidays.
- Retail Promotions: Many department stores are leveraging Presidents' Day for significant sales, particularly in furniture and appliances, aiming to attract consumers and boost sales, reflecting retailers' strategic approaches during holiday periods.
See More
Amazon: The Smartest Growth Stock to Buy Now
- Attractive Valuation: Amazon's stock is currently trading at about 26.5 times the 2026 expected P/E ratio, significantly lower than valuations of traditional retailers like Walmart and Costco, making it one of the cheapest investment opportunities in its history and attracting investor interest.
- Operational Efficiency Gains: With over 1 million robots deployed in its distribution centers and coordinated by the DeepFleet AI model, Amazon has not only increased delivery speed but also significantly enhanced operational efficiency, driving sales growth.
- Advertising Revenue Surge: Amazon's high-margin sponsored ad business saw a 22% revenue increase last quarter, becoming a key driver of its operating income growth and further solidifying its leading position in the global digital advertising space.
- Cloud Computing Market Leadership: Holding the number one market share in cloud computing, Amazon's revenue growth reached 24% in Q4, the highest in over three years, indicating its commitment to invest $200 billion in capital expenditures to meet the booming demand for AI infrastructure.
See More
Walmart Investors Should Exercise Caution Ahead of Earnings Report
- Strong Stock Performance: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% year-to-date, reaching an adjusted all-time high, and has gained nearly 29% over the past 12 months, indicating robust market performance that attracts investor interest.
- Analyst Optimism: Analysts at Oppenheimer expect Walmart's fourth-quarter holiday sales to come in at the high end of the projected growth range of 3.75% to 4.75%, reflecting market confidence in its sales performance, which could further boost the stock price.
- Market Share Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income consumers through modernized stores and online pickup services, enhancing its position in the competitive retail market and encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks Emerge: Despite Walmart reaching a $1 trillion market cap, its price-to-earnings ratio stands at 45, the highest since 2021, indicating that the stock may be overvalued, prompting investors to carefully consider their buying timing.
See More
Walmart Stock Soars to All-Time High
- Stock Surge: Walmart's stock has surged approximately 20% this year, reaching an all-time high and surpassing a $1 trillion market cap, making it the 12th company to achieve this milestone, indicating strong performance in the retail sector.
- Analyst Upgrades: Several analysts have raised Walmart's price targets, with Oppenheimer expecting fourth-quarter holiday sales to hit the high end of the projected growth range of 3.75% to 4.75%, reflecting market optimism about its sales outlook.
- Customer Base Expansion: Walmart has successfully attracted higher-income shoppers while maintaining its traditional budget-conscious clientele, enhancing its market competitiveness through modernized stores and online pickup services, thereby encroaching on rival Target's market share.
- Valuation Risks: Despite Walmart's strong performance, its price-to-earnings ratio has reached 45 times, the highest since 2021, prompting analysts to advise caution for investors considering purchases, as profit-taking may occur post-earnings report.
See More
Key Companies to Monitor This Week: PCE, Walmart, Palo Alto, Analog Devices, Deere, and Others
- Market Performance: Equities experienced a decline last week, with all three major indexes falling by at least 1.2%.
- Economic Indicators: This downturn occurred despite a better-than-expected jobs report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and a relatively stable inflation report.
See More
