Merchants Bancorp (MBIN) is not a good buy for a beginner, long-term investor at this moment. The technical indicators show a bearish trend, financial performance has significantly declined, and there are no strong positive catalysts to support an immediate investment decision. Additionally, insider selling and weak stock trend probabilities further discourage a buy recommendation.
The MACD is negative and expanding (-0.685), indicating bearish momentum. RSI is neutral at 33.021, and moving averages are converging, showing no clear trend. The stock is trading near its support level (S1: 41.454), with the pre-market price at 41.91, suggesting limited upside potential.

Hedge funds are significantly increasing their buying activity, with a 19170.47% increase in the last quarter. Analysts have raised the price target to $51, citing tailwinds from loan growth, net interest margin, and capital return.
Insiders are heavily selling, with a 945.56% increase in selling activity over the last month. Financial performance in Q4 2025 showed a significant decline in revenue (-4.56% YoY), net income (-30.78% YoY), and EPS (-30.81% YoY). Stock trend analysis shows a 50% chance of a -8.39% drop in the next week and -8.29% in the next month.
In Q4 2025, revenue dropped to $161.81M (-4.56% YoY), net income fell to $58.80M (-30.78% YoY), and EPS declined to $1.28 (-30.81% YoY). Gross margin remained unchanged.
Morgan Stanley raised the price target from $42 to $51, maintaining an Equal Weight rating. The firm remains optimistic about midcap banks due to loan growth and capital return but notes that recent outperformance sets a higher bar for future gains.