Post Holdings Appoints Nicolas Catoggio as New CEO
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: 3 days ago
0mins
Should l Buy POST?
Post Holdings announced that Robert Vitale, Post's Chairman and CEO, will become Executive Chairman on October 1, 2026, and Nicolas Catoggio, Post's Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, will transition to President and CEO of Post. "Nico is an exceptional leader," Vitale said. "Over the past several years, he has driven strong performance at Post Consumer Brands, led integration of acquisitions, and earned the trust of our teams across the organization. He has the right judgement and experience to lead the company as we continue to execute our strategy to create long-term value for our shareholders."
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy POST?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on POST
Wall Street analysts forecast POST stock price to rise
7 Analyst Rating
6 Buy
1 Hold
0 Sell
Strong Buy
Current: 102.050
Low
108.00
Averages
121.71
High
130.00
Current: 102.050
Low
108.00
Averages
121.71
High
130.00
About POST
Post Holdings, Inc. is a consumer-packaged goods holding company with businesses operating in the center-of-the-store, refrigerated, foodservice and food ingredient categories. Its businesses include Post Consumer Brands, Weetabix, Michael Foods, and Bob Evans Farms. Its segments include Post Consumer Brands, Weetabix, Foodservice, and Refrigerated Retail. Post Consumer Brands segment manufactures, markets and sells human and pet food products, primarily in the ready-to-eat (RTE) cereal, granola, hot cereal, nut butter and dog and cat food categories in North America. Weetabix segment markets and distributes branded and private label RTE cereal products. Weetabix is a manufacturer's breakfast cereals category, with its brands being Weetabix and Alpen. Foodservice segment produces and distributes egg and potato products through the foodservice and food ingredient channels. Refrigerated Retail segment produces and distributes side dishes, eggs and egg products, sausage, and others.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Post Holdings Q2 2026 Earnings Call Insights
- Performance Exceeds Expectations: Post Holdings reported adjusted EBITDA above expectations for Q2 2026, yet maintained its full-year EBITDA guidance due to new headwinds from the Middle East conflict, demonstrating resilience in a challenging environment.
- Capital Return Strategy: The company has reduced its share count by 15% year-to-date through aggressive buybacks, indicating strong cash flow and liquidity that provide flexibility for capital allocation, thereby enhancing investor confidence.
- CEO Succession Plans: Management highlighted a smooth transition in CEO succession, indicating stability during leadership changes and reinforcing confidence in the company's strategic direction moving forward.
- Market Pricing Strategy: Management noted that in response to inflationary pressures, the company will adjust pricing strategies based on the duration of cost pressures, showcasing its keen responsiveness to market dynamics and flexibility in operations.
See More
Post Holdings Q2 Earnings Beat Expectations
- Earnings Beat: Post Holdings reported a Q2 Non-GAAP EPS of $1.94, exceeding expectations by $0.19, indicating strong profitability despite revenue falling short of projections.
- Revenue Growth Lags: Revenue increased by 4.6% year-over-year to $2.04 billion, yet missed expectations by $30 million, reflecting intensified market competition and fluctuations in consumer demand impacting sales.
- Stable Outlook: Management affirmed its fiscal year 2026 adjusted EBITDA guidance range of $1.55 billion to $1.58 billion, demonstrating confidence in future profitability despite external challenges.
- Capital Expenditure Plans: Projected capital expenditures for fiscal year 2026 are expected to range between $350 million and $390 million, including ongoing investments in cage-free egg facility expansion and the completion of the Norwalk, Iowa precooked egg facility expansion, totaling $80 million to $90 million.
See More
Post Holdings Reports Strong Q2 Results with Increased Earnings
- Significant Sales Growth: Post Holdings reported net sales of $2.0429 billion for Q2, a 4.7% increase year-over-year, including $152.3 million from acquisitions, indicating strong market performance and successful acquisition strategies.
- Improved Profitability: The company achieved a gross profit of $617.6 million in Q2, representing 30.2% of net sales, up 13.2% from the previous year, demonstrating effective cost control and pricing strategies.
- Increased Adjusted Net Earnings: Adjusted net earnings for Q2 reached $104.7 million, an 18.1% increase from $88.7 million in the prior year, reflecting improvements in operational efficiency and market demand.
- Enhanced Shareholder Returns: The company repurchased 3.3 million shares for $331 million in Q2, emphasizing its commitment to shareholder returns, while the board approved a new $600 million share repurchase authorization, further boosting market confidence.
See More
BellRing Brands Shares Plunge 46.9% After Disappointing Q2 Report
- Disappointing Performance: BellRing Brands reported only 2% year-over-year sales growth in Q2 2026, significantly below the analyst consensus of 3.5%, with adjusted earnings plummeting from $0.53 to $0.14 per share, indicating weakness in market competitiveness.
- Guidance Downgrade: Management has revised full-year sales growth expectations down from 5% to 1%, with adjusted EBITDA now projected at approximately $325 million, a 25% reduction from the previous estimate of $433 million, reflecting a challenging market environment.
- Intensifying Competition: The sales growth of BellRing Brands has heavily relied on deep discount promotions, which have eroded profit margins and raised concerns about organic demand, as the CEO noted that retailers will focus on the most successful brands amidst increasing competition in the protein shake market.
- Stock Volatility: BellRing's stock has crashed 87% over the past year, trading at just 6.8 times trailing earnings, presenting investors with either a potential turnaround opportunity or the risk of further declines, leaving the market uncertain about its future performance.
See More
BellRing Brands Stock Plummets After Q2 Earnings Miss
- Earnings Decline: BellRing Brands reported a significant drop in adjusted earnings per share from $0.53 to $0.14 for Q2 FY2026, falling short of the analyst consensus of $0.32, which triggered a nearly 47% plunge in stock price, indicating severe deterioration in profitability.
- Weak Sales Growth: Although the company achieved a 2% year-over-year sales growth in Q2, management has lowered its full-year sales growth forecast to 1%, down from 5% three months ago, highlighting significant challenges in market competition, particularly under pressure from discount promotions.
- Margin Pressure: The company's profit margins have been severely impacted by deep discount promotions and rising raw material costs, with adjusted EBITDA now expected to be approximately $325 million, a 25% decrease from the previous guidance of $433 million, reflecting difficulties in maintaining profitability.
- Intensifying Competition: CEO Darcy Davenport, who is set to retire, noted that BellRing faces increasing competition in the protein shake market, especially within warehouse club retail channels, suggesting that future market share will be increasingly concentrated among successful brands, adding strategic pressure on the company.
See More
Investment Opportunities in Consumer Goods Amid Market Volatility
- Post Holdings Potential: Post Holdings (POST), a cereal and convenience food company, is projected to achieve significant earnings growth over the next 12 months, with a market cap of $4.9 billion and a stock price of $101.59, indicating strong pricing power and stability amid market volatility.
- Utz Brands Market Positioning: Utz Brands (UTZ) focuses on high-velocity products while cutting underperforming units, and despite limited media coverage, it holds a significant position in the salty snack market characterized by strong brand loyalty, showcasing robust long-term investment value.
- Hormel Foods Resilience: Hormel Foods (HRL), a 'Dividend King' with 60 consecutive years of dividend increases, currently has a market cap of $12 billion and a stock price of $21.16, attracting consumers during economic downturns and demonstrating stability and appeal in uncertain markets.
- Clorox Innovation Investment: Clorox (CLX), while facing private-label competition, is investing in innovation and marketing to maintain market share, with a market cap of $13 billion and a stock price of $104.58, indicating its long-term investment potential in the essential goods market.
See More
Post Holdings Q2 2026 Earnings Call Insights
- Performance Exceeds Expectations: Post Holdings reported adjusted EBITDA above expectations for Q2 2026, yet maintained its full-year EBITDA guidance due to new headwinds from the Middle East conflict, demonstrating resilience in a challenging environment.
- Capital Return Strategy: The company has reduced its share count by 15% year-to-date through aggressive buybacks, indicating strong cash flow and liquidity that provide flexibility for capital allocation, thereby enhancing investor confidence.
- CEO Succession Plans: Management highlighted a smooth transition in CEO succession, indicating stability during leadership changes and reinforcing confidence in the company's strategic direction moving forward.
- Market Pricing Strategy: Management noted that in response to inflationary pressures, the company will adjust pricing strategies based on the duration of cost pressures, showcasing its keen responsiveness to market dynamics and flexibility in operations.
See More
Post Holdings Q2 Earnings Beat Expectations
- Earnings Beat: Post Holdings reported a Q2 Non-GAAP EPS of $1.94, exceeding expectations by $0.19, indicating strong profitability despite revenue falling short of projections.
- Revenue Growth Lags: Revenue increased by 4.6% year-over-year to $2.04 billion, yet missed expectations by $30 million, reflecting intensified market competition and fluctuations in consumer demand impacting sales.
- Stable Outlook: Management affirmed its fiscal year 2026 adjusted EBITDA guidance range of $1.55 billion to $1.58 billion, demonstrating confidence in future profitability despite external challenges.
- Capital Expenditure Plans: Projected capital expenditures for fiscal year 2026 are expected to range between $350 million and $390 million, including ongoing investments in cage-free egg facility expansion and the completion of the Norwalk, Iowa precooked egg facility expansion, totaling $80 million to $90 million.
See More
Post Holdings Reports Strong Q2 Results with Increased Earnings
- Significant Sales Growth: Post Holdings reported net sales of $2.0429 billion for Q2, a 4.7% increase year-over-year, including $152.3 million from acquisitions, indicating strong market performance and successful acquisition strategies.
- Improved Profitability: The company achieved a gross profit of $617.6 million in Q2, representing 30.2% of net sales, up 13.2% from the previous year, demonstrating effective cost control and pricing strategies.
- Increased Adjusted Net Earnings: Adjusted net earnings for Q2 reached $104.7 million, an 18.1% increase from $88.7 million in the prior year, reflecting improvements in operational efficiency and market demand.
- Enhanced Shareholder Returns: The company repurchased 3.3 million shares for $331 million in Q2, emphasizing its commitment to shareholder returns, while the board approved a new $600 million share repurchase authorization, further boosting market confidence.
See More
BellRing Brands Shares Plunge 46.9% After Disappointing Q2 Report
- Disappointing Performance: BellRing Brands reported only 2% year-over-year sales growth in Q2 2026, significantly below the analyst consensus of 3.5%, with adjusted earnings plummeting from $0.53 to $0.14 per share, indicating weakness in market competitiveness.
- Guidance Downgrade: Management has revised full-year sales growth expectations down from 5% to 1%, with adjusted EBITDA now projected at approximately $325 million, a 25% reduction from the previous estimate of $433 million, reflecting a challenging market environment.
- Intensifying Competition: The sales growth of BellRing Brands has heavily relied on deep discount promotions, which have eroded profit margins and raised concerns about organic demand, as the CEO noted that retailers will focus on the most successful brands amidst increasing competition in the protein shake market.
- Stock Volatility: BellRing's stock has crashed 87% over the past year, trading at just 6.8 times trailing earnings, presenting investors with either a potential turnaround opportunity or the risk of further declines, leaving the market uncertain about its future performance.
See More
BellRing Brands Stock Plummets After Q2 Earnings Miss
- Earnings Decline: BellRing Brands reported a significant drop in adjusted earnings per share from $0.53 to $0.14 for Q2 FY2026, falling short of the analyst consensus of $0.32, which triggered a nearly 47% plunge in stock price, indicating severe deterioration in profitability.
- Weak Sales Growth: Although the company achieved a 2% year-over-year sales growth in Q2, management has lowered its full-year sales growth forecast to 1%, down from 5% three months ago, highlighting significant challenges in market competition, particularly under pressure from discount promotions.
- Margin Pressure: The company's profit margins have been severely impacted by deep discount promotions and rising raw material costs, with adjusted EBITDA now expected to be approximately $325 million, a 25% decrease from the previous guidance of $433 million, reflecting difficulties in maintaining profitability.
- Intensifying Competition: CEO Darcy Davenport, who is set to retire, noted that BellRing faces increasing competition in the protein shake market, especially within warehouse club retail channels, suggesting that future market share will be increasingly concentrated among successful brands, adding strategic pressure on the company.
See More
Investment Opportunities in Consumer Goods Amid Market Volatility
- Post Holdings Potential: Post Holdings (POST), a cereal and convenience food company, is projected to achieve significant earnings growth over the next 12 months, with a market cap of $4.9 billion and a stock price of $101.59, indicating strong pricing power and stability amid market volatility.
- Utz Brands Market Positioning: Utz Brands (UTZ) focuses on high-velocity products while cutting underperforming units, and despite limited media coverage, it holds a significant position in the salty snack market characterized by strong brand loyalty, showcasing robust long-term investment value.
- Hormel Foods Resilience: Hormel Foods (HRL), a 'Dividend King' with 60 consecutive years of dividend increases, currently has a market cap of $12 billion and a stock price of $21.16, attracting consumers during economic downturns and demonstrating stability and appeal in uncertain markets.
- Clorox Innovation Investment: Clorox (CLX), while facing private-label competition, is investing in innovation and marketing to maintain market share, with a market cap of $13 billion and a stock price of $104.58, indicating its long-term investment potential in the essential goods market.
See More
