How Is Allstate’s Stock Performance Compared to Other P&C Insurers?
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Mar 17 2025
0mins
Should l Buy ALL?
Source: NASDAQ.COM
Company Overview: The Allstate Corporation, based in Northbrook, Illinois, is a major player in the property and casualty insurance market with a market cap of $55 billion, ranking as the fourth largest P&C insurer and second largest home insurance provider in the U.S.
Stock Performance: Allstate's stock has shown strong growth, gaining 5.7% over the past three months and 30.2% over the past year, despite a slight dip following mixed Q4 results; analysts maintain a "Moderate Buy" rating with a price target suggesting an 8.8% upside from current levels.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy ALL?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on ALL
Wall Street analysts forecast ALL stock price to rise
16 Analyst Rating
9 Buy
6 Hold
1 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 214.180
Low
207.00
Averages
239.64
High
281.00
Current: 214.180
Low
207.00
Averages
239.64
High
281.00
About ALL
The Allstate Corporation protects people from life’s uncertainties with a wide array of protection for autos, homes, electronic devices and identity theft. The Company’s products are available through Allstate agents, independent agents, major retailers, online and at the workplace. Its Allstate Protection segment offers private passenger auto, homeowners, other personal lines and commercial insurance. Its Run-off Property-Liability segment includes property and casualty insurance coverage. The Company’s Protection Services segment provides consumer product protection plans, device and mobile data collection services and analytic solutions using automotive telematics information, roadside assistance, protection and insurance products and identity protection and restoration through Allstate Protection Plans, Allstate Dealer Services, Allstate Roadside, Arity and Allstate Identity Protection.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Goldman Sachs Upgrades AIG to Buy Amid AI Impact Assessment
- Rating Changes: Goldman Sachs upgraded American International Group (AIG) to Buy, reflecting anticipated peer-high EPS growth and improving ROE over the coming years, which is expected to drive stock price appreciation and enhance investor confidence.
- Market Reaction: AIG shares rose 2.65% to $80.38 in pre-market trading on Thursday, indicating a positive market response to Goldman’s new rating, potentially attracting more investor interest in the stock.
- Allstate Rating Downgrade: Conversely, Goldman downgraded Allstate (ALL) to Neutral, considering increasing near-term fundamental risks and the impact of AI on the insurance sector, suggesting a cautious outlook on its future performance.
- Industry Outlook: Goldman noted that commercial insurers and reinsurers are best positioned against AI risks, indicating that these companies are expected to outperform other insurance brokers in the near term, reflecting differing market perceptions of AI technology's potential impact.
See More
Latest Rating Changes on Wall Street
- Semiconductor Opportunities: Loop initiates coverage of Astera Labs with a buy rating, highlighting the company's potential across all generative AI silicon solutions that address critical pain points in AI server and cluster experiences, which could enhance its market share.
- Auto Parts Investment Advice: Deutsche Bank upgrades Dauch Corporation from hold to buy, suggesting that investors should seize the opportunity amid recent stock weakness before an acquisition, with expectations that the company's margin targets will be supported going forward.
- Vacation Market Outlook: Mizuho upgrades Marriott Vacations from market perform to outperform, raising the price target from $58 to $104, indicating a 52% upside potential that reflects strong prospects in the vacation market.
- Insurance Sector Dynamics: Goldman Sachs upgrades AIG from neutral to buy, citing strong earnings growth potential, particularly as AIG's improving return on equity stands out amidst peers facing decelerating earnings growth due to cyclical pressures.
See More
Berkshire Hathaway Reports Significant Decline in Q4 Operating Earnings
- Operating Earnings Decline: Berkshire Hathaway reported Q4 operating earnings of $10.2 billion, down 29% year-over-year, primarily due to weakness in its insurance business, highlighting challenges in its diversified operations.
- Insurance Business Losses: Insurance underwriting profits plummeted 54% to $1.56 billion, while investment income fell nearly 25% to $3.1 billion, reflecting pressures in the insurance market and its impact on overall profitability.
- Annual Overall Earnings Drop: Total overall earnings for 2025 fell to $66.97 billion from $89 billion the previous year, indicating volatility in investment performance and potential implications for shareholders.
- Cash Reserves Slightly Decrease: Despite no stock buybacks, Berkshire's cash reserves dipped from $381.6 billion to $373.3 billion, demonstrating a cautious approach to capital allocation and reflecting its strategy in navigating market fluctuations.
See More
Lemonade's Five-Year Growth Outlook
- Significant Customer Growth: By the end of 2025, Lemonade's customer base is projected to reach 2.98 million, nearly tripling from 1 million at the end of 2020, highlighting its appeal among younger consumers and market potential.
- Revenue Growth Expectations: Lemonade anticipates a 46% CAGR in revenue from 2025 to 2027, with adjusted EBITDA expected to turn positive by 2026, indicating an improvement in profitability.
- Reasonable Market Valuation: With an enterprise value of $4.2 billion, Lemonade's stock trades at 3.5 times this year's sales, reflecting a reasonable valuation given its future growth potential.
- Strategic Expansion Plans: The company aims to grow its in-force premiums (IFP) from $944 million in 2024 to $10 billion, and if achieved, its stock price could triple by 2030, demonstrating its ability to continually attract new customers and expand its product platform.
See More
State Farm Announces Historic $5 Billion Cash Back to Auto Customers
- Historic Dividend: State Farm has announced a $5 billion dividend for auto insurance customers, marking the largest payout in its 103-year history, reflecting the company's financial strength and better-than-expected underwriting performance.
- Average Customer Refund: Customers can expect an average refund of $100, although the amount will vary by state and premium paid, aiming to enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty amidst rising costs.
- Premium Reduction Trend: State Farm has lowered premiums by about 10% across 40 states, totaling $4.6 billion in savings for customers, indicating a broader trend in the auto insurance industry despite a 50% increase in rates over the past three years.
- Intensifying Market Competition: Economic pressures are driving consumers to seek competitive insurance options, putting State Farm under pressure from competitors like Progressive, which also announced significant customer dividends in 2025, highlighting the evolving dynamics of the market.
See More
Allstate to Present at Raymond James Investors Conference
- Presentation Schedule: Allstate's President, Jess Merten, will present at the Raymond James 47th Annual Institutional Investors Conference on March 2, 2026, at 6:30 a.m. CT, outlining the company's strategic direction in property and liability insurance.
- Webcast Availability: The presentation will be accessible via a live webcast on Allstate's investor website, with a replay available shortly after the event, ensuring investors can obtain key information and engage with the content.
- Financial Transparency: Allstate routinely posts financial information and material announcements on its investor website, reflecting the company's commitment to transparency, which helps to bolster investor confidence.
- Broad Insurance Coverage: Allstate currently has 211 million policies in force, offering a wide range of insurance products including auto, home, electronic devices, and identity protection, showcasing its strong competitive position and market share in the insurance sector.
See More
Goldman Sachs Upgrades AIG to Buy Amid AI Impact Assessment
- Rating Changes: Goldman Sachs upgraded American International Group (AIG) to Buy, reflecting anticipated peer-high EPS growth and improving ROE over the coming years, which is expected to drive stock price appreciation and enhance investor confidence.
- Market Reaction: AIG shares rose 2.65% to $80.38 in pre-market trading on Thursday, indicating a positive market response to Goldman’s new rating, potentially attracting more investor interest in the stock.
- Allstate Rating Downgrade: Conversely, Goldman downgraded Allstate (ALL) to Neutral, considering increasing near-term fundamental risks and the impact of AI on the insurance sector, suggesting a cautious outlook on its future performance.
- Industry Outlook: Goldman noted that commercial insurers and reinsurers are best positioned against AI risks, indicating that these companies are expected to outperform other insurance brokers in the near term, reflecting differing market perceptions of AI technology's potential impact.
See More
Latest Rating Changes on Wall Street
- Semiconductor Opportunities: Loop initiates coverage of Astera Labs with a buy rating, highlighting the company's potential across all generative AI silicon solutions that address critical pain points in AI server and cluster experiences, which could enhance its market share.
- Auto Parts Investment Advice: Deutsche Bank upgrades Dauch Corporation from hold to buy, suggesting that investors should seize the opportunity amid recent stock weakness before an acquisition, with expectations that the company's margin targets will be supported going forward.
- Vacation Market Outlook: Mizuho upgrades Marriott Vacations from market perform to outperform, raising the price target from $58 to $104, indicating a 52% upside potential that reflects strong prospects in the vacation market.
- Insurance Sector Dynamics: Goldman Sachs upgrades AIG from neutral to buy, citing strong earnings growth potential, particularly as AIG's improving return on equity stands out amidst peers facing decelerating earnings growth due to cyclical pressures.
See More
Berkshire Hathaway Reports Significant Decline in Q4 Operating Earnings
- Operating Earnings Decline: Berkshire Hathaway reported Q4 operating earnings of $10.2 billion, down 29% year-over-year, primarily due to weakness in its insurance business, highlighting challenges in its diversified operations.
- Insurance Business Losses: Insurance underwriting profits plummeted 54% to $1.56 billion, while investment income fell nearly 25% to $3.1 billion, reflecting pressures in the insurance market and its impact on overall profitability.
- Annual Overall Earnings Drop: Total overall earnings for 2025 fell to $66.97 billion from $89 billion the previous year, indicating volatility in investment performance and potential implications for shareholders.
- Cash Reserves Slightly Decrease: Despite no stock buybacks, Berkshire's cash reserves dipped from $381.6 billion to $373.3 billion, demonstrating a cautious approach to capital allocation and reflecting its strategy in navigating market fluctuations.
See More
Lemonade's Five-Year Growth Outlook
- Significant Customer Growth: By the end of 2025, Lemonade's customer base is projected to reach 2.98 million, nearly tripling from 1 million at the end of 2020, highlighting its appeal among younger consumers and market potential.
- Revenue Growth Expectations: Lemonade anticipates a 46% CAGR in revenue from 2025 to 2027, with adjusted EBITDA expected to turn positive by 2026, indicating an improvement in profitability.
- Reasonable Market Valuation: With an enterprise value of $4.2 billion, Lemonade's stock trades at 3.5 times this year's sales, reflecting a reasonable valuation given its future growth potential.
- Strategic Expansion Plans: The company aims to grow its in-force premiums (IFP) from $944 million in 2024 to $10 billion, and if achieved, its stock price could triple by 2030, demonstrating its ability to continually attract new customers and expand its product platform.
See More
State Farm Announces Historic $5 Billion Cash Back to Auto Customers
- Historic Dividend: State Farm has announced a $5 billion dividend for auto insurance customers, marking the largest payout in its 103-year history, reflecting the company's financial strength and better-than-expected underwriting performance.
- Average Customer Refund: Customers can expect an average refund of $100, although the amount will vary by state and premium paid, aiming to enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty amidst rising costs.
- Premium Reduction Trend: State Farm has lowered premiums by about 10% across 40 states, totaling $4.6 billion in savings for customers, indicating a broader trend in the auto insurance industry despite a 50% increase in rates over the past three years.
- Intensifying Market Competition: Economic pressures are driving consumers to seek competitive insurance options, putting State Farm under pressure from competitors like Progressive, which also announced significant customer dividends in 2025, highlighting the evolving dynamics of the market.
See More
Allstate to Present at Raymond James Investors Conference
- Presentation Schedule: Allstate's President, Jess Merten, will present at the Raymond James 47th Annual Institutional Investors Conference on March 2, 2026, at 6:30 a.m. CT, outlining the company's strategic direction in property and liability insurance.
- Webcast Availability: The presentation will be accessible via a live webcast on Allstate's investor website, with a replay available shortly after the event, ensuring investors can obtain key information and engage with the content.
- Financial Transparency: Allstate routinely posts financial information and material announcements on its investor website, reflecting the company's commitment to transparency, which helps to bolster investor confidence.
- Broad Insurance Coverage: Allstate currently has 211 million policies in force, offering a wide range of insurance products including auto, home, electronic devices, and identity protection, showcasing its strong competitive position and market share in the insurance sector.
See More
