Capital One Initiates Equalweight Rating on Casey's General Stores
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Jun 18 2025
0mins
Source: 4
Casey's General Stores Inc. (CASY) has seen a decline of 6.26% as it hits a 5-day low, reflecting investor concerns amid mixed market conditions.
Capital One Securities has initiated an Equalweight rating on Casey's, citing that while the management team and self-distribution model are strong, market expectations are too high. They project only 8% to 10% EBITDA growth for FY27, which contrasts with the company's previous high growth rates. This significant slowdown in expected growth may impact investor confidence, contributing to the stock's recent decline.
The market's reaction to Casey's rating reflects broader concerns about future earnings growth in the retail sector, especially as analysts adjust their expectations based on recent performance metrics.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy CASY?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on CASY
Wall Street analysts forecast CASY stock price to fall
10 Analyst Rating
6 Buy
4 Hold
0 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 784.710
Low
530.00
Averages
609.33
High
700.00
Current: 784.710
Low
530.00
Averages
609.33
High
700.00
About CASY
Casey's General Stores, Inc. and its subsidiaries operate approximately 2,900 convenience stores in 19 states. It offers freshly prepared foods such as regular and breakfast pizza, donuts, hot breakfast items, and hot and cold sandwiches), beverages, tobacco and nicotine products, groceries, health and beauty aids, automotive products, and other non-food items. It offers a range of fuels, including E-10 gasoline, High Octane gasoline, Biodiesel, Winterized diesel, and Ethanol-free gasoline. It sells a range of tobacco products, including cigarettes, E- cigarettes and vapor, chewing tobacco nicotine pouches, and rolling paper and accessories. Its subsidiaries operate convenience stores primarily under the names Casey's and Casey's General Store. The Company also operates stores under additional brands such as GoodStop or CEFCO. These locations offer fuel for sale, and a broad selection of snacks, beverages, tobacco products, and other essentials.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Buc-ee's Accelerates Expansion Plans with 15 New Locations
- Expansion Plans: Buc-ee's is set to open 15 new locations across the South, Southwest, and Midwest, rapidly increasing its market share and directly competing with Casey's General Stores (CASY), potentially reshaping the regional convenience store landscape.
- New Store Opening: The opening of a 74,000 square foot travel center in Goodyear, Arizona, marks Buc-ee's strategic expansion in the U.S., expected to attract a significant number of travelers and enhance brand visibility.
- Market Competition: Despite differences in customer base and product offerings, both Buc-ee's and Casey's rely on gasoline sales to draw customers, indicating that competition in the Midwest will intensify in the future.
- Brand Advantages: Buc-ee's is renowned for its extensive product selection and clean restroom facilities, which are likely to attract more customers, especially along highways, while Casey's maintains a convenience advantage in local markets.
See More
Casey's Unveils Three-Year Strategy to Add 400 Stores
- Clear Strategic Goals: Casey's General Stores has announced a plan to add at least 400 stores over the next three years through acquisitions and new store construction, demonstrating its commitment to expanding in the convenience retail market and aiming to increase market share.
- Strong Financial Performance: In the recently concluded fiscal year, Casey's net income rose 30.7% to $714.4 million, while EBITDA increased 23.6% to nearly $1.5 billion, indicating that the company exceeded its financial targets under the previous strategic plan.
- Investment Focus Areas: The company will continue to invest in its food and beverage business, expand its private-brand offerings, and enhance operational efficiency through technology and data-driven tools aimed at improving food preparation, customer service, and store operations.
- Optimistic Future Outlook: Casey's expects same-store sales growth of 2% to 5% for fiscal 2027, with inside margins above 42%, and forecasts EBITDA growth of 8% to 10%, reflecting strong profitability and sustainable growth potential.
See More
Casey's Investor Day Highlights Pizza and Wings Growth Potential
- Pizza Business Growth: At its Investor Day, Casey's (CASY) emphasized its pizza segment, ranking as the fifth largest pizza chain in the U.S. by kitchen count, and significantly improved the ordering experience by reducing clicks from 11 to 3.
- Customer Retention Strategy: Casey's is successfully reviving lapsed customers and attracting new ones, particularly during college football Saturdays, leading to a substantial increase in orders and outperforming traditional pizza chains in same-store sales.
- Wings Business Outlook: Looking ahead, Casey's aims for chicken wings to be the next growth platform, supported by data indicating that customers ordering wings tend to have higher average baskets and increased visitation rates, showcasing strong market potential.
- Market Reaction and Analysis: Despite the positive growth outlook presented at the Investor Day, Casey's (CASY) shares fell 4.8% in afternoon trading; RBC Capital Markets analyst noted that S&P 500 inclusion, a $1B buyback authorization, and the scaling of wings chainwide by FY29 will support continued re-rating of the stock.
See More
Casey’s Unveils New Three-Year Strategic Plan
- Accelerating Food and Beverage Growth: Casey’s plans to continue investing in made-to-order offerings, including pizza and chicken wings, with expectations to roll out new products across nearly 3,000 stores, driving sales growth, particularly with a 20% year-over-year increase in wing sales in Des Moines, indicating strong market demand.
- Store Expansion Strategy: The company aims to add at least 400 stores through acquisitions and new store development, leveraging its successful integration of CEFCO in Texas to further expand market share and enhance brand presence.
- Enhancing Operational Efficiency: Casey’s is investing in technology and data-driven tools to improve food preparation and customer service efficiency, which will enhance forecasting capabilities and customer experience, thereby supporting profitable growth.
- Long-Term Value Creation: The strategic plan aims to continuously enhance market share and profitability through food business expansion and store network growth, ensuring long-term value creation for shareholders and reflecting its unique competitive advantage in the convenience retail sector.
See More
Capital One Initiates Coverage on Casey's and Murphy USA with Divergent Ratings
- Casey's Rating Analysis: Capital One Securities initiated an Equalweight rating on Casey's General Stores (CASY), noting that while the management team and self-distribution model are strong, market expectations are too high, with a razor-thin margin for error at current trading multiples, projecting only 8% to 10% EBITDA growth for FY27.
- EBITDA Growth Trend: Analysts highlighted that Casey's has experienced year-over-year quarterly EBITDA growth in the high teens, 20s, and 30s over the past few years, indicating that the market has become accustomed to this growth level, yet future guidance suggests a significant slowdown, which may impact investor confidence.
- Murphy USA Rating Upgrade: In contrast, Murphy USA (MUSA) received an Overweight rating from Capital One, with analysts believing that structural fuel margin gains from last year and early this year are not being fully recognized by the market, which should drive the durability and growth potential of the company's cash flows.
- Price Target Setting: Capital One set a price target of $896 for Casey's based on a 20x multiple applied to near-term adjusted EBITDA estimates, while Murphy USA's price target is set at $710, reflecting confidence in its low-cost retail operating model.
See More
Oil Price Fluctuations and Economic Data in Focus
- Oil Price Forecast: With increased crude exports through the Strait of Hormuz and the U.S. Navy lifting its blockade, Jim Cramer anticipates that if peace negotiations with Iran continue to progress, oil prices could see a 'shockingly lower' drop, easing inflationary pressures and supporting potential interest rate cuts.
- Travel Demand Impact: Carnival is set to report earnings before the bell on Monday, which Cramer believes will reveal the effects of the Iran war on travel and the implications of recent fuel price declines on demand, although he favors Viking Holdings for its upscale customer base and pricing power.
- Housing Market Focus: Cramer notes that KB Home's earnings report will provide insights into the impact of elevated interest rates on housing demand, stating that the housing market feels 'dead in the water' and deserves more attention from central bankers.
- Semiconductor Industry Outlook: Micron Technology is scheduled to report earnings on Wednesday, which Cramer calls 'the most consequential quarter of the week,' emphasizing that the company must significantly exceed expectations and raise guidance to maintain its stock rally.
See More
Buc-ee's Accelerates Expansion Plans with 15 New Locations
- Expansion Plans: Buc-ee's is set to open 15 new locations across the South, Southwest, and Midwest, rapidly increasing its market share and directly competing with Casey's General Stores (CASY), potentially reshaping the regional convenience store landscape.
- New Store Opening: The opening of a 74,000 square foot travel center in Goodyear, Arizona, marks Buc-ee's strategic expansion in the U.S., expected to attract a significant number of travelers and enhance brand visibility.
- Market Competition: Despite differences in customer base and product offerings, both Buc-ee's and Casey's rely on gasoline sales to draw customers, indicating that competition in the Midwest will intensify in the future.
- Brand Advantages: Buc-ee's is renowned for its extensive product selection and clean restroom facilities, which are likely to attract more customers, especially along highways, while Casey's maintains a convenience advantage in local markets.
See More
Casey's Unveils Three-Year Strategy to Add 400 Stores
- Clear Strategic Goals: Casey's General Stores has announced a plan to add at least 400 stores over the next three years through acquisitions and new store construction, demonstrating its commitment to expanding in the convenience retail market and aiming to increase market share.
- Strong Financial Performance: In the recently concluded fiscal year, Casey's net income rose 30.7% to $714.4 million, while EBITDA increased 23.6% to nearly $1.5 billion, indicating that the company exceeded its financial targets under the previous strategic plan.
- Investment Focus Areas: The company will continue to invest in its food and beverage business, expand its private-brand offerings, and enhance operational efficiency through technology and data-driven tools aimed at improving food preparation, customer service, and store operations.
- Optimistic Future Outlook: Casey's expects same-store sales growth of 2% to 5% for fiscal 2027, with inside margins above 42%, and forecasts EBITDA growth of 8% to 10%, reflecting strong profitability and sustainable growth potential.
See More
Casey's Investor Day Highlights Pizza and Wings Growth Potential
- Pizza Business Growth: At its Investor Day, Casey's (CASY) emphasized its pizza segment, ranking as the fifth largest pizza chain in the U.S. by kitchen count, and significantly improved the ordering experience by reducing clicks from 11 to 3.
- Customer Retention Strategy: Casey's is successfully reviving lapsed customers and attracting new ones, particularly during college football Saturdays, leading to a substantial increase in orders and outperforming traditional pizza chains in same-store sales.
- Wings Business Outlook: Looking ahead, Casey's aims for chicken wings to be the next growth platform, supported by data indicating that customers ordering wings tend to have higher average baskets and increased visitation rates, showcasing strong market potential.
- Market Reaction and Analysis: Despite the positive growth outlook presented at the Investor Day, Casey's (CASY) shares fell 4.8% in afternoon trading; RBC Capital Markets analyst noted that S&P 500 inclusion, a $1B buyback authorization, and the scaling of wings chainwide by FY29 will support continued re-rating of the stock.
See More
Casey’s Unveils New Three-Year Strategic Plan
- Accelerating Food and Beverage Growth: Casey’s plans to continue investing in made-to-order offerings, including pizza and chicken wings, with expectations to roll out new products across nearly 3,000 stores, driving sales growth, particularly with a 20% year-over-year increase in wing sales in Des Moines, indicating strong market demand.
- Store Expansion Strategy: The company aims to add at least 400 stores through acquisitions and new store development, leveraging its successful integration of CEFCO in Texas to further expand market share and enhance brand presence.
- Enhancing Operational Efficiency: Casey’s is investing in technology and data-driven tools to improve food preparation and customer service efficiency, which will enhance forecasting capabilities and customer experience, thereby supporting profitable growth.
- Long-Term Value Creation: The strategic plan aims to continuously enhance market share and profitability through food business expansion and store network growth, ensuring long-term value creation for shareholders and reflecting its unique competitive advantage in the convenience retail sector.
See More
Capital One Initiates Coverage on Casey's and Murphy USA with Divergent Ratings
- Casey's Rating Analysis: Capital One Securities initiated an Equalweight rating on Casey's General Stores (CASY), noting that while the management team and self-distribution model are strong, market expectations are too high, with a razor-thin margin for error at current trading multiples, projecting only 8% to 10% EBITDA growth for FY27.
- EBITDA Growth Trend: Analysts highlighted that Casey's has experienced year-over-year quarterly EBITDA growth in the high teens, 20s, and 30s over the past few years, indicating that the market has become accustomed to this growth level, yet future guidance suggests a significant slowdown, which may impact investor confidence.
- Murphy USA Rating Upgrade: In contrast, Murphy USA (MUSA) received an Overweight rating from Capital One, with analysts believing that structural fuel margin gains from last year and early this year are not being fully recognized by the market, which should drive the durability and growth potential of the company's cash flows.
- Price Target Setting: Capital One set a price target of $896 for Casey's based on a 20x multiple applied to near-term adjusted EBITDA estimates, while Murphy USA's price target is set at $710, reflecting confidence in its low-cost retail operating model.
See More
Oil Price Fluctuations and Economic Data in Focus
- Oil Price Forecast: With increased crude exports through the Strait of Hormuz and the U.S. Navy lifting its blockade, Jim Cramer anticipates that if peace negotiations with Iran continue to progress, oil prices could see a 'shockingly lower' drop, easing inflationary pressures and supporting potential interest rate cuts.
- Travel Demand Impact: Carnival is set to report earnings before the bell on Monday, which Cramer believes will reveal the effects of the Iran war on travel and the implications of recent fuel price declines on demand, although he favors Viking Holdings for its upscale customer base and pricing power.
- Housing Market Focus: Cramer notes that KB Home's earnings report will provide insights into the impact of elevated interest rates on housing demand, stating that the housing market feels 'dead in the water' and deserves more attention from central bankers.
- Semiconductor Industry Outlook: Micron Technology is scheduled to report earnings on Wednesday, which Cramer calls 'the most consequential quarter of the week,' emphasizing that the company must significantly exceed expectations and raise guidance to maintain its stock rally.
See More
