American Eagle Outfitters Leads Apparel Retail Stocks in Year-to-Date Performance
Consumer Discretionary Sector Performance: The S&P 500 consumer discretionary sector has gained +7.2% year-to-date in 2025, underperforming compared to the overall S&P 500, which has a higher performance. The sector ranks eighth among 11 major sectors.
Top Performing Apparel Retail Stocks: American Eagle Outfitters leads the apparel retail stocks with a YTD performance of +65.21%, followed by Urban Outfitters at +49.53%. Other notable performers include Victoria’s Secret & Co. and Boot Barn Holdings, with the latter having a Strong Buy rating.
Underperformers in the Sector: Burlington Stores, Revolve Group, and Abercrombie & Fitch are the three companies that have posted negative year-to-date performances, indicating challenges within certain segments of the consumer discretionary market.
Quant Ratings Overview: The report includes a list of top apparel stocks with their respective Quant Ratings, highlighting that Boot Barn Holdings is one of only two stocks with a Strong Buy rating, while several others maintain Hold ratings.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Analyst Views on XLY
About the author


Morgan Stanley's Price Target Update: Morgan Stanley raised its price target on Dutch Bros to $85 from $82, maintaining an overweight rating, while RBC Capital lowered its target to $75 from $80 but kept an outperform rating.
Strong Q4 Performance: Dutch Bros reported Q4 revenues of $443.6 million, exceeding expectations of $424.9 million, and demonstrated a 29.4% increase in revenue year-over-year.
Analyst Ratings and Market Sentiment: Analysts have varied ratings on Dutch Bros, with some maintaining buy ratings and others lowering price targets, reflecting a mix of optimism and caution in the market.
Future Projections: Dutch Bros announced plans for significant capital expenditures in 2026, projecting revenues between $2 billion and $2.03 billion, with same-store sales growth estimated at 3% to 5%.
Consumer Discretionary Performance: Consumer discretionary stocks have seen minimal growth, with only a 2% increase over the past year as indicated by the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF.
Comparison with Other S&P Sectors: Among the 11 major S&P sectors, consumer discretionary stocks performed poorly, with only financials showing worse performance, remaining unchanged over the same period.
S&P 500 Growth: In contrast, the S&P 500 has experienced a more robust gain of 12% over the past year, highlighting the underperformance of consumer discretionary and financial sectors.
Market Trends: The overall market trends suggest a challenging environment for consumer discretionary stocks, reflecting broader economic conditions affecting consumer spending.

- Market Dynamics: The stock market is characterized by rapid changes, where previously popular stocks can quickly lose favor.
- Investor Strategy: Investors are increasingly looking back at former stock picks to identify potential opportunities for profit.
- Stock Price Prediction: Predicting stock prices is inherently challenging due to market volatility and numerous influencing factors.
- Weather Pattern Prediction: Forecasting weather patterns proves to be even more complex, highlighting the difficulties in making accurate predictions in both fields.

Market Dynamics: Stock markets are continuously changing, with past stock picks potentially becoming new investment opportunities as trends evolve.
Technical Reset: Many previously strong stocks are undergoing technical resets after consolidations or pullbacks, indicating potential for renewed growth.
Investor Patience: Investors who are patient may find rewarding setups in stocks that are beginning to show signs of recovery.
Revisiting Stocks: It is beneficial to revisit earlier stock selections that may now present fresh opportunities due to recent market adjustments.







