Based on the provided data, here's an analysis of whether BANF is overvalued:
Recent Financial Performance
BancFirst reported Q4 2024 GAAP EPS of $1.68 with revenue of $162.9M, showing an 8.4% year-over-year growth. However, Seeking Alpha has downgraded BancFirst to a "Sell" rating, indicating expectations for flat earnings going forward.
Concerning Insider Activity
Executive Vice President Darryl Schmidt recently sold 5,000 shares (~10.3% of his holdings) for $610,315, and notably, there have been 75 insider sales with zero purchases over the past six months. This consistent selling pattern from insiders suggests potential concerns about valuation.
Institutional Sentiment
While 110 institutional investors increased their positions last quarter, 97 decreased theirs, showing mixed but slightly positive institutional sentiment.
Market Position
Despite some positive market commentary suggesting regional banks like BancFirst could be well-positioned for recovery, the consistent insider selling and analyst downgrades raise significant valuation concerns.
Conclusion
BANF appears overvalued at current levels due to flat earnings expectations, significant insider selling patterns, and mixed institutional sentiment despite decent quarterly results.