Bank First Completes Acquisition of Centre 1 Bancorp, Q1 Net Interest Income Rises
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Apr 16 2026
0mins
Reports Q1 net interest margin 3.96% vs. 4.01% for the previous quarter and 3.65% for 1Q25. Tangible book value per share totaled $47.04 at March 31, 2026, vs. $46.01 at December 31, 2025. Q1 net interest income was $53.2M, up $13.1M from the previous quarter and up $16.7M from 1Q25."On January 1, 2026, we successfully completed our acquisition of Centre 1 Bancorp, Inc., the holding company for First National Bank and Trust, headquartered in Beloit, Wisconsin. This acquisition marked another milestone in Bank First's long-term growth strategy and established our new Stateline Region...The integration of these specialized services is already enhancing our ability to deliver comprehensive financial solutions across our legacy markets, and we are actively investing in the continued build-out of our Wealth Management platform throughout our footprint. As part of our disciplined integration strategy, six overlapping First National Bank and Trust branches were permanently closed upon completion of the acquisition. In addition, we are planning to build new, modern offices in Walworth, Delavan, and Monroe. These new locations will strengthen our long-term presence in high-potential relationship markets while allowing us to consolidate and close two additional First National Bank and Trust branches," said Mike Molepske, Chairman and CEO of Bank First Corporation.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy BFC?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on BFC
Wall Street analysts forecast BFC stock price to fall
1 Analyst Rating
0 Buy
1 Hold
0 Sell
Hold
Current: 144.610
Low
142.00
Averages
142.00
High
142.00
Current: 144.610
Low
142.00
Averages
142.00
High
142.00
About BFC
Bank First Corporation provides financial services through its subsidiary, Bank First, N.A. (the Bank). The Bank is a full-service community bank, offering business and retail products and services in communities throughout Wisconsin and Illinois. The Bank serves businesses, professionals and consumers with a variety of financial services, including retail and commercial banking. The Bank's products include checking accounts, savings accounts, money market accounts, cash management accounts, certificates of deposit, commercial and industrial loans, commercial real estate loans, construction and development loans, residential mortgages, consumer loans, credit cards, online banking, telephone banking and mobile banking. It also provides a variety of loans to individuals for personal and household purposes, including secured and unsecured installment loans and revolving lines of credit. It offers a number of in-house mortgage products, including adjustable-rate mortgages.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Zacks Adds Three Stocks to Strong Sell List
- ATS Corporation Downgrade: ATS Corporation, an industrial automation company, has seen its current year earnings estimate revised downward by 10.4% over the past 60 days, indicating weakened market confidence that could pressure its stock price.
- Bank First Corporation Warning: As a holding company for Bank First, Bank First Corporation's current year earnings estimate has been cut by 8.2% in the last 60 days, reflecting operational challenges that may impact investor sentiment.
- Commercial Metals Company Decline: Commercial Metals Company, a player in the steel and metals sector, has had its current year earnings estimate reduced by 5.2% over the past 60 days, which could negatively affect its stock price, prompting caution among investors.
- Future Investment Opportunities: Despite three stocks being added to the Strong Sell list, the Zacks team has identified five stocks with the potential to gain over 100% in the future, indicating that there are still potential investment opportunities in the market.
See More
Small-Cap Financial Stocks Rated Least Attractive
- Valuation Overview: Bank First, Eagle Bancorp, and Esquire Financial Holdings are rated as the least attractive U.S. small-cap financial stocks according to Seeking Alpha's valuation grades, indicating significant valuation risks relative to peers.
- Assessment Criteria: Seeking Alpha's valuation grades utilize multiple metrics, including P/E, PEG, EV/Sales, and EV/EBITDA, to comprehensively evaluate a stock's pricing attractiveness within its sector, highlighting competitive disadvantages for these companies.
- Specific Ratings: All three companies—Bank First Corporation, Eagle Bancorp, and Esquire Financial Holdings—received an F rating, suggesting they are perceived as overvalued in both current and forward market expectations, which may undermine investor confidence.
- Market Impact: The low valuation ratings of these small-cap financial stocks may prompt investors to reassess their portfolios, potentially leading to capital outflows and further price declines, thereby affecting overall market sentiment and the performance of small-cap financial stocks.
See More
Bank First Corporation to Acquire PSB Holdings for $202.9M
- Acquisition Scale: Bank First Corporation announced its plan to acquire PSB Holdings for approximately $202.9 million in an all-stock transaction, significantly expanding its market share and enhancing its competitive position in the financial services industry.
- Shareholder Exchange Rights: Under the terms of the agreement, each Peoples shareholder will have the right to receive 0.3470 of a share of Bank First's common stock for each share of Peoples common stock, providing shareholders with a direct opportunity for equity appreciation.
- Positive Market Reaction: Following the acquisition announcement, Bank First's stock price rose by 1.99% in premarket trading to $146.23, reflecting the market's positive outlook on the transaction and increased investor confidence.
- Strategic Integration Potential: This acquisition is expected to not only enhance Bank First's asset base but also improve operational efficiency through resource and customer base integration, thereby laying a solid foundation for future growth.
See More
Bank First Acquires PSB Holdings to Expand Market Presence
- Strategic Merger: Bank First has entered into a merger agreement with PSB Holdings valued at approximately $202.9 million, which is expected to enhance the market competitiveness and service capabilities of both banks, solidifying their community banking presence in Wisconsin.
- Asset Growth: Post-merger, Bank First will have over $7.6 billion in assets, with total loans around $5.64 billion and deposits approximately $6.27 billion, significantly enhancing its financial service capacity and potential to support individuals and businesses.
- Shareholder Value Enhancement: PSB Holdings shareholders are expected to receive over an 80% market premium, and by partnering with a publicly traded company with a long history of uninterrupted quarterly dividends, they will benefit from increased liquidity and investment appeal.
- Customer Service Expansion: The merger will allow customers of both banks to access a broader range of products and services, including advanced digital banking solutions and comprehensive treasury management services, thereby enhancing customer experience and satisfaction.
See More
Analysis of Recent Insider Buying Activities
- Bank First Insider Purchase: Director Todd A. Sprang bought 450 shares of BFC at $138.96 each on Wednesday, totaling $62,532, indicating confidence in the company's future performance, with a 4% gain at the day's peak.
- Stock Performance: Currently, Bank First's stock is up about 1.8%, reflecting a positive market reaction to insider buying, which may bolster investor confidence in the company.
- NeOnc Purchase Details: President Amir F. Heshmatpour purchased 10,000 shares of NeOnc Technologies Holdings at $4.90 each for a total of $49,000 on Thursday, demonstrating optimism about the company's future prospects.
- Historical Investment Overview: Heshmatpour has made four prior purchases of NeOnc over the past year, totaling $469,008 at an average cost of $5.86 per share, despite the current 2.3% decline in stock price, indicating confidence in the company's long-term value.
See More
Bank First (BFC) Announces 10% Dividend Increase to $0.55 per Share
- Dividend Increase: Bank First has declared a quarterly dividend increase from $0.50 to $0.55 per share, representing a 10% rise, which reflects the company's strong performance in maintaining profitability and cash flow, thereby boosting investor confidence.
- Yield Context: The forward yield of 1.54% may be relatively low, yet it still attracts investors seeking stable returns, indicating the company's competitive position among small-cap stocks despite the lower yield grade.
- Payment Details: The new dividend will be payable on July 8, with a record date of June 24 and an ex-dividend date also set for June 24, ensuring shareholders can promptly benefit from the dividend, which further strengthens shareholder relations.
- Financial Health: The dividend increase aligns with Bank First's historical earnings data, demonstrating the company's ongoing commitment to financial management and shareholder returns, which enhances its reputation and attractiveness in the market.
See More
Zacks Adds Three Stocks to Strong Sell List
- ATS Corporation Downgrade: ATS Corporation, an industrial automation company, has seen its current year earnings estimate revised downward by 10.4% over the past 60 days, indicating weakened market confidence that could pressure its stock price.
- Bank First Corporation Warning: As a holding company for Bank First, Bank First Corporation's current year earnings estimate has been cut by 8.2% in the last 60 days, reflecting operational challenges that may impact investor sentiment.
- Commercial Metals Company Decline: Commercial Metals Company, a player in the steel and metals sector, has had its current year earnings estimate reduced by 5.2% over the past 60 days, which could negatively affect its stock price, prompting caution among investors.
- Future Investment Opportunities: Despite three stocks being added to the Strong Sell list, the Zacks team has identified five stocks with the potential to gain over 100% in the future, indicating that there are still potential investment opportunities in the market.
See More
Small-Cap Financial Stocks Rated Least Attractive
- Valuation Overview: Bank First, Eagle Bancorp, and Esquire Financial Holdings are rated as the least attractive U.S. small-cap financial stocks according to Seeking Alpha's valuation grades, indicating significant valuation risks relative to peers.
- Assessment Criteria: Seeking Alpha's valuation grades utilize multiple metrics, including P/E, PEG, EV/Sales, and EV/EBITDA, to comprehensively evaluate a stock's pricing attractiveness within its sector, highlighting competitive disadvantages for these companies.
- Specific Ratings: All three companies—Bank First Corporation, Eagle Bancorp, and Esquire Financial Holdings—received an F rating, suggesting they are perceived as overvalued in both current and forward market expectations, which may undermine investor confidence.
- Market Impact: The low valuation ratings of these small-cap financial stocks may prompt investors to reassess their portfolios, potentially leading to capital outflows and further price declines, thereby affecting overall market sentiment and the performance of small-cap financial stocks.
See More
Bank First Corporation to Acquire PSB Holdings for $202.9M
- Acquisition Scale: Bank First Corporation announced its plan to acquire PSB Holdings for approximately $202.9 million in an all-stock transaction, significantly expanding its market share and enhancing its competitive position in the financial services industry.
- Shareholder Exchange Rights: Under the terms of the agreement, each Peoples shareholder will have the right to receive 0.3470 of a share of Bank First's common stock for each share of Peoples common stock, providing shareholders with a direct opportunity for equity appreciation.
- Positive Market Reaction: Following the acquisition announcement, Bank First's stock price rose by 1.99% in premarket trading to $146.23, reflecting the market's positive outlook on the transaction and increased investor confidence.
- Strategic Integration Potential: This acquisition is expected to not only enhance Bank First's asset base but also improve operational efficiency through resource and customer base integration, thereby laying a solid foundation for future growth.
See More
Bank First Acquires PSB Holdings to Expand Market Presence
- Strategic Merger: Bank First has entered into a merger agreement with PSB Holdings valued at approximately $202.9 million, which is expected to enhance the market competitiveness and service capabilities of both banks, solidifying their community banking presence in Wisconsin.
- Asset Growth: Post-merger, Bank First will have over $7.6 billion in assets, with total loans around $5.64 billion and deposits approximately $6.27 billion, significantly enhancing its financial service capacity and potential to support individuals and businesses.
- Shareholder Value Enhancement: PSB Holdings shareholders are expected to receive over an 80% market premium, and by partnering with a publicly traded company with a long history of uninterrupted quarterly dividends, they will benefit from increased liquidity and investment appeal.
- Customer Service Expansion: The merger will allow customers of both banks to access a broader range of products and services, including advanced digital banking solutions and comprehensive treasury management services, thereby enhancing customer experience and satisfaction.
See More
Analysis of Recent Insider Buying Activities
- Bank First Insider Purchase: Director Todd A. Sprang bought 450 shares of BFC at $138.96 each on Wednesday, totaling $62,532, indicating confidence in the company's future performance, with a 4% gain at the day's peak.
- Stock Performance: Currently, Bank First's stock is up about 1.8%, reflecting a positive market reaction to insider buying, which may bolster investor confidence in the company.
- NeOnc Purchase Details: President Amir F. Heshmatpour purchased 10,000 shares of NeOnc Technologies Holdings at $4.90 each for a total of $49,000 on Thursday, demonstrating optimism about the company's future prospects.
- Historical Investment Overview: Heshmatpour has made four prior purchases of NeOnc over the past year, totaling $469,008 at an average cost of $5.86 per share, despite the current 2.3% decline in stock price, indicating confidence in the company's long-term value.
See More
Bank First (BFC) Announces 10% Dividend Increase to $0.55 per Share
- Dividend Increase: Bank First has declared a quarterly dividend increase from $0.50 to $0.55 per share, representing a 10% rise, which reflects the company's strong performance in maintaining profitability and cash flow, thereby boosting investor confidence.
- Yield Context: The forward yield of 1.54% may be relatively low, yet it still attracts investors seeking stable returns, indicating the company's competitive position among small-cap stocks despite the lower yield grade.
- Payment Details: The new dividend will be payable on July 8, with a record date of June 24 and an ex-dividend date also set for June 24, ensuring shareholders can promptly benefit from the dividend, which further strengthens shareholder relations.
- Financial Health: The dividend increase aligns with Bank First's historical earnings data, demonstrating the company's ongoing commitment to financial management and shareholder returns, which enhances its reputation and attractiveness in the market.
See More
