PSQ Holdings CFO James Rinn Resigns, Michael Pena Appointed
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Apr 07 2026
0mins
Should l Buy PSQH?
PSQ Holdings announced that James Rinn, Chief Financial Officer, has resigned from his role, effective April 30, 2026, to pursue another opportunity. Rinn will remain a Class III Director after stepping down as CFO. Following Rinn's departure, effective May 1, 2026, Michael Pena, current Senior Vice President of Finance for the company, has been named Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer. Additionally, Krista Wenzel, the company's current Senior Vice President of Finance and Accounting, has been named Chief Accounting Officer, effective May 1, 2026. Dusty Wunderlich, Chairman & CEO of PSQ Holdings, commented, "I want to thank James for his leadership and significant contributions over the past year, particularly in helping guide the Company through a transition to a focused fintech business and improving our cost structure. We wish James the best in his future endeavors and appreciate his continued commitment to serving on our Board of Directors.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy PSQH?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on PSQH
Wall Street analysts forecast PSQH stock price to rise
2 Analyst Rating
2 Buy
0 Hold
0 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 0.716
Low
3.50
Averages
4.00
High
4.50
Current: 0.716
Low
3.50
Averages
4.00
High
4.50
About PSQH
PSQ Holdings, Inc. provides a commerce and payments ecosystem that serves an audience of consumers and merchants. It operates under three segments: Financial Technology, Marketplace and Brands. The Financial Technology segment includes Credova, a consumer financing and payments company. The PSQ Marketplace (the Platform) is its primary customer and merchant acquisition tool. The Marketplace segment includes a Mobile application, which comprises a mobile app that is available for both iOS and Android-based devices, and Web-users can access its full platform at PublicSquare.com. The Brands segment comprises EveryLife, a direct-to-consumer (D2C) life-affirming baby products company. It leverages data and insights from the Marketplace to assess its customers’ needs and provide wholly owned quality financial products and brands. Credova is a Buy Now Pay Later company focused on the outdoors and shooting sports industry. Its Marketplace is free to join for both consumers and business owners.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
PSQ Holdings Appoints New CFO and CAO
- Executive Changes: PSQ Holdings announced the appointment of Michael Pena as CFO and Treasurer effective May 1, 2026, while James Rinn will resign as CFO on April 30, 2026; Pena's extensive experience in structured finance and fintech is expected to enhance the company's financial management capabilities.
- New CAO Appointment: Krista Wenzel has been named Chief Accounting Officer effective May 1, 2026, and her deep knowledge of capital markets and enterprise finance will likely improve the company's financial transparency and compliance, thereby boosting investor confidence.
- Background Experience: Pena's successful tenure as CFO at Credova, where he facilitated an acquisition in March 2024, showcases his capabilities in investor relations and operations, while Wenzel's previous CFO roles in infrastructure investment platforms are expected to provide strategic financial insights for PSQ Holdings.
- Board Transition: Although Rinn is stepping down as CFO, he will remain a Class III Director, which will help ensure stability during the transition and leverage Rinn's experience to support the new executive team's operations.
See More
PSQ Holdings Announces CFO Transition
- CFO Resignation: James Rinn, CFO of PSQ Holdings, will resign effective April 30, 2026, while remaining on the Board, a move that may impact the company's financial strategy and investor confidence.
- New CFO Appointment: Michael Pena will take over as CFO and Treasurer on May 1, 2026, and his successful track record at Credova is expected to drive further development in the fintech sector for the company.
- Accounting Officer Appointment: Krista Wenzel will be appointed Chief Accounting Officer on May 1, 2026, and her extensive experience in financial reporting and controls will enhance the company's financial transparency and compliance.
- Strategic Shift: This leadership transition reflects PSQ Holdings' strategic shift towards a fintech business model, with the new finance team focusing on capital allocation and operational finance to support long-term growth objectives.
See More
PSQ HOLDINGS INC APPOINTS MICHAEL PENA AS CFO AND TREASURER STARTING MAY 1, 2026
- New Appointment: Michael Pena has been named Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and Treasurer of Holdings Inc.
- Effective Date: His appointment will take effect on May 1, 2026.
See More
PSQ HOLDINGS INC - JAMES RINN WILL CONTINUE AS BOARD MEMBER FOLLOWING CFO RESIGNATION
James Rinn's Position: James Rinn remains on the board of directors after stepping down as Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of the company.
Company Leadership Changes: The transition in leadership reflects ongoing changes within the company's executive team.
See More
PSQ Holdings to Speak at Roth Investor Conference
- Investor Conference Participation: PSQ Holdings' CEO Dusty Wunderlich will participate in a fireside chat at the 38th Annual Roth Investor Conference on March 24, 2026, showcasing the company's strategic vision in the payments and financial infrastructure sector.
- Webcast Arrangement: The conference webcast will begin at 10:30 a.m. PT, allowing investors to log in 15 minutes early via the company website to stay updated on the latest company developments and market trends.
- One-on-One Investor Meetings: Management will host one-on-one meetings with institutional investors during the conference to discuss recent financial results, business trends, and growth opportunities, aiming to bolster investor confidence and attract more capital.
- Company Background: PSQ Holdings focuses on providing compliant payment solutions for industries underserved by traditional financial institutions, dedicated to building and operating financial infrastructure in highly regulated environments to meet the needs of businesses, campaigns, and nonprofits.
See More
PSQ Holdings Q4 2025 Earnings Call Insights
- Significant Revenue Growth: PSQ Holdings reported net revenue of $18.2 million for Q4 2025, an 81% increase from $10.1 million in 2024, exceeding previous guidance of $16.5 million, showcasing strong performance in the fintech sector.
- Effective Cost Control: The company reduced SG&A expenses by $9.9 million year-over-year, with headcount decreasing from 87 to approximately 50, indicating strategic decisions aimed at simplifying structure and enhancing cash efficiency, which is expected to drive significant revenue per employee growth in 2026.
- AI Adoption Enhances Efficiency: By implementing machine learning and AI-driven credit scoring models within the Credova credit platform, PSQ Holdings has seen meaningful improvements in underwriting performance, reflecting the company's ongoing commitment to technological innovation.
- Positive Future Outlook: Management anticipates focusing on driving revenue per employee and cash efficiency in 2026, completing divestitures of non-core assets, and leveraging automation and AI to expand revenue, aiming to achieve profitability goals.
See More
PSQ Holdings Appoints New CFO and CAO
- Executive Changes: PSQ Holdings announced the appointment of Michael Pena as CFO and Treasurer effective May 1, 2026, while James Rinn will resign as CFO on April 30, 2026; Pena's extensive experience in structured finance and fintech is expected to enhance the company's financial management capabilities.
- New CAO Appointment: Krista Wenzel has been named Chief Accounting Officer effective May 1, 2026, and her deep knowledge of capital markets and enterprise finance will likely improve the company's financial transparency and compliance, thereby boosting investor confidence.
- Background Experience: Pena's successful tenure as CFO at Credova, where he facilitated an acquisition in March 2024, showcases his capabilities in investor relations and operations, while Wenzel's previous CFO roles in infrastructure investment platforms are expected to provide strategic financial insights for PSQ Holdings.
- Board Transition: Although Rinn is stepping down as CFO, he will remain a Class III Director, which will help ensure stability during the transition and leverage Rinn's experience to support the new executive team's operations.
See More
PSQ Holdings Announces CFO Transition
- CFO Resignation: James Rinn, CFO of PSQ Holdings, will resign effective April 30, 2026, while remaining on the Board, a move that may impact the company's financial strategy and investor confidence.
- New CFO Appointment: Michael Pena will take over as CFO and Treasurer on May 1, 2026, and his successful track record at Credova is expected to drive further development in the fintech sector for the company.
- Accounting Officer Appointment: Krista Wenzel will be appointed Chief Accounting Officer on May 1, 2026, and her extensive experience in financial reporting and controls will enhance the company's financial transparency and compliance.
- Strategic Shift: This leadership transition reflects PSQ Holdings' strategic shift towards a fintech business model, with the new finance team focusing on capital allocation and operational finance to support long-term growth objectives.
See More
PSQ HOLDINGS INC APPOINTS MICHAEL PENA AS CFO AND TREASURER STARTING MAY 1, 2026
- New Appointment: Michael Pena has been named Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and Treasurer of Holdings Inc.
- Effective Date: His appointment will take effect on May 1, 2026.
See More
PSQ HOLDINGS INC - JAMES RINN WILL CONTINUE AS BOARD MEMBER FOLLOWING CFO RESIGNATION
James Rinn's Position: James Rinn remains on the board of directors after stepping down as Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of the company.
Company Leadership Changes: The transition in leadership reflects ongoing changes within the company's executive team.
See More
PSQ Holdings to Speak at Roth Investor Conference
- Investor Conference Participation: PSQ Holdings' CEO Dusty Wunderlich will participate in a fireside chat at the 38th Annual Roth Investor Conference on March 24, 2026, showcasing the company's strategic vision in the payments and financial infrastructure sector.
- Webcast Arrangement: The conference webcast will begin at 10:30 a.m. PT, allowing investors to log in 15 minutes early via the company website to stay updated on the latest company developments and market trends.
- One-on-One Investor Meetings: Management will host one-on-one meetings with institutional investors during the conference to discuss recent financial results, business trends, and growth opportunities, aiming to bolster investor confidence and attract more capital.
- Company Background: PSQ Holdings focuses on providing compliant payment solutions for industries underserved by traditional financial institutions, dedicated to building and operating financial infrastructure in highly regulated environments to meet the needs of businesses, campaigns, and nonprofits.
See More
PSQ Holdings Q4 2025 Earnings Call Insights
- Significant Revenue Growth: PSQ Holdings reported net revenue of $18.2 million for Q4 2025, an 81% increase from $10.1 million in 2024, exceeding previous guidance of $16.5 million, showcasing strong performance in the fintech sector.
- Effective Cost Control: The company reduced SG&A expenses by $9.9 million year-over-year, with headcount decreasing from 87 to approximately 50, indicating strategic decisions aimed at simplifying structure and enhancing cash efficiency, which is expected to drive significant revenue per employee growth in 2026.
- AI Adoption Enhances Efficiency: By implementing machine learning and AI-driven credit scoring models within the Credova credit platform, PSQ Holdings has seen meaningful improvements in underwriting performance, reflecting the company's ongoing commitment to technological innovation.
- Positive Future Outlook: Management anticipates focusing on driving revenue per employee and cash efficiency in 2026, completing divestitures of non-core assets, and leveraging automation and AI to expand revenue, aiming to achieve profitability goals.
See More
