GoDaddy Shares Drop Despite Earnings Beat Amid Revenue Concerns
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Oct 24 2024
0mins
Should l Buy GDDY?
GoDaddy's shares fell 16.11% after crossing below the 5-day SMA, reflecting investor concerns despite a positive earnings report.
The company's Q4 2025 earnings report exceeded EPS estimates, but GoDaddy forecasted annual revenue below expectations, anticipating between $5.20 billion and $5.28 billion, which is lower than Wall Street's average estimate of $5.29 billion. This revenue downgrade, driven by slow adoption of AI tools, has raised skepticism about the company's growth potential, leading to a significant drop in stock price.
The decline in GoDaddy's stock highlights the challenges the company faces in restoring investor confidence. With the need for strategic adjustments in its market approach, GoDaddy must address these concerns to improve its outlook and stabilize its stock performance.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy GDDY?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on GDDY
Wall Street analysts forecast GDDY stock price to rise
16 Analyst Rating
8 Buy
8 Hold
0 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 90.210
Low
85.00
Averages
166.38
High
240.00
Current: 90.210
Low
85.00
Averages
166.38
High
240.00
About GDDY
GoDaddy Inc. is engaged in serving a market of entrepreneurs, developing and delivering easy-to-use products in a one-stop shop solution alongside personalized guidance. The Company serves small businesses, individuals, organizations, developers, designers and domain investors. The Company's segments include Applications and Commerce (A&C) and Core Platform (Core). The A&C segment primarily consists of sales of products containing proprietary software, notably its Website building products, as well as its commerce products and third-party email and productivity solutions and sales of certain products when they are included in bundled offerings of its proprietary software products. The Core segment primarily consists of sales of domain registrations and renewals, aftermarket domain sales, Website hosting products and Website security products when not included in bundled offerings of its proprietary software products, as well as sales of products not containing a software component.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
GOODNOW Investment Group Increases Stake in Maplebear
- Investment Increase: GOODNOW Investment Group added 131,723 shares of Maplebear (CART) in Q4 2025, raising its stake to 5.78%, with the investment value increasing by $16.17 million, indicating strong confidence in the company.
- Market Performance: As of February 16, 2026, Maplebear's share price stood at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, reflecting market concerns about its future growth.
- Business Model Shift: Maplebear connects consumers with personal shoppers for rapid online grocery shopping and delivery, and as consumers return to physical stores, investor focus has shifted from delivery growth to the underlying marketplace economics.
- Advertising Revenue Growth: Instacart's profitability increasingly relies on advertising revenue rather than delivery fees, with brands significantly increasing spending on promotions within the app, making advertising a key driver of earnings and potentially reducing reliance on delivery economics in the future.
See More
GOODNOW Investment Group Increases Stake in Maplebear
- Increased Stake: GOODNOW Investment Group acquired an additional 131,723 shares of Maplebear (NASDAQ:CART) during Q4 2025, with an estimated transaction value of $5.39 million, indicating confidence in the company's potential.
- Value Growth: The position's value increased by $16.17 million at quarter-end, reflecting both trading activities and stock price changes, suggesting a positive market outlook for Maplebear's future.
- Asset Management Proportion: The new stake totals 1,377,881 shares valued at $61.98 million, representing 5.78% of GOODNOW's 13F reportable AUM, which, while not in the top five holdings, still signifies a strategic investment decision.
- Market Performance Analysis: As of February 16, 2026, Maplebear's shares were priced at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, highlighting investor concerns regarding its evolving profitability model.
See More
Goodnow Investment Group Increases Stake in Instacart
- Stake Increase: Goodnow Investment Group added 131,723 shares of Maplebear (NASDAQ: CART) in Q4 2025, raising its stake to 5.78%, with the investment value increasing by $16.17 million, reflecting confidence in Instacart's growth potential.
- Market Performance: As of February 16, 2026, CART shares were priced at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, indicating market concerns regarding its evolving profitability model.
- Profitability Shift: Instacart's profitability increasingly relies on advertising revenue rather than delivery fees, as consumer packaged goods companies pay to promote products within the app, offering significantly higher margins, which may influence investor perceptions of its future value.
- Market Competition: As more retailers join the Instacart platform and brands increase marketing spend, advertising inventory grows with transaction volume, potentially strengthening Instacart's position in the grocery ecosystem and reducing reliance on delivery economics.
See More
GoDaddy Listed Among 13 Most Undervalued S&P 500 Stocks
- Price Target Cuts: Evercore ISI lowered its price target on GoDaddy from $145 to $95 while maintaining an In Line rating, indicating market caution regarding the company's future growth prospects.
- Revenue Guidance Miss: Citi reduced its price target from $195 to $110 but kept a Buy rating, noting that the 2026 revenue guidance fell short of expectations, highlighting potential in GoDaddy's new offerings.
- Earnings Report: GoDaddy reported Q4 EPS of $1.80, exceeding the consensus of $1.59, while Q4 revenue matched expectations at $1.27 billion, demonstrating the company's ability to maintain stable revenue.
- Growth Slowdown: Cantor Fitzgerald cut its price target from $130 to $90, citing a slowdown in bookings growth to 5% due to a new go-to-market strategy and domain promotions, with Q1 and FY26 revenue growth guidance slightly below prior estimates.
See More
Bullish Thesis on GoDaddy Inc. Highlights Investment Opportunity
- Stable Cash Flow: GoDaddy Inc. owns over 84 million domains, and despite a roughly 50% decline in market capitalization over the past year, its free cash flow remains robust, with expectations to generate between $1.2 billion and $1.6 billion, supporting buybacks and potential debt reduction.
- Share Repurchase Strategy: Since 2022, GoDaddy has reduced its share count by over 25%, creating a self-reinforcing growth engine through aggressive buyback programs, even in the absence of extraordinary organic growth.
- Market Mispricing: The market currently misprices GoDaddy as a commoditized registrar facing structural growth risks, underestimating the value of its recurring cash flows and repurchase program, with base-case valuations suggesting upside to $24 billion.
- Risks and Opportunities: While risks such as leverage constraints, AI-driven platform changes, and competitive pricing pressures exist, GoDaddy's sticky revenue and disciplined capital allocation offer an attractive risk/reward profile for investors.
See More
GoDaddy Under Investigation for Possible Securities Law Violations
- Financial Performance Disclosure: GoDaddy's Q4 2025 financial results, released on February 24, 2026, revealed bookings of $1.28 million, with the introduction of a promotional price for .com domains leading to a decline in upfront bookings and near-term revenue, indicating competitive pressures in the market.
- Revenue Guidance Downgrade: The company provided 2026 revenue guidance of $5.195 billion to $5.275 billion, anticipating a modest impact on revenue growth rates in both Core Platform and A&C segments due to the promotional pricing, suggesting strategic adjustments in response to market dynamics.
- Significant Stock Price Drop: Following the earnings report, GoDaddy's stock price fell by $13.16, or 14.26%, closing at $79.14 on February 25, 2026, reflecting investor concerns regarding the company's future performance.
- Investor Rights Protection: Glancy Prongay Wolke & Rotter LLP has initiated an investigation into GoDaddy to protect investor rights, encouraging affected investors to pursue claims, highlighting the law firm's commitment to safeguarding shareholder interests.
See More
GOODNOW Investment Group Increases Stake in Maplebear
- Investment Increase: GOODNOW Investment Group added 131,723 shares of Maplebear (CART) in Q4 2025, raising its stake to 5.78%, with the investment value increasing by $16.17 million, indicating strong confidence in the company.
- Market Performance: As of February 16, 2026, Maplebear's share price stood at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, reflecting market concerns about its future growth.
- Business Model Shift: Maplebear connects consumers with personal shoppers for rapid online grocery shopping and delivery, and as consumers return to physical stores, investor focus has shifted from delivery growth to the underlying marketplace economics.
- Advertising Revenue Growth: Instacart's profitability increasingly relies on advertising revenue rather than delivery fees, with brands significantly increasing spending on promotions within the app, making advertising a key driver of earnings and potentially reducing reliance on delivery economics in the future.
See More
GOODNOW Investment Group Increases Stake in Maplebear
- Increased Stake: GOODNOW Investment Group acquired an additional 131,723 shares of Maplebear (NASDAQ:CART) during Q4 2025, with an estimated transaction value of $5.39 million, indicating confidence in the company's potential.
- Value Growth: The position's value increased by $16.17 million at quarter-end, reflecting both trading activities and stock price changes, suggesting a positive market outlook for Maplebear's future.
- Asset Management Proportion: The new stake totals 1,377,881 shares valued at $61.98 million, representing 5.78% of GOODNOW's 13F reportable AUM, which, while not in the top five holdings, still signifies a strategic investment decision.
- Market Performance Analysis: As of February 16, 2026, Maplebear's shares were priced at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, highlighting investor concerns regarding its evolving profitability model.
See More
Goodnow Investment Group Increases Stake in Instacart
- Stake Increase: Goodnow Investment Group added 131,723 shares of Maplebear (NASDAQ: CART) in Q4 2025, raising its stake to 5.78%, with the investment value increasing by $16.17 million, reflecting confidence in Instacart's growth potential.
- Market Performance: As of February 16, 2026, CART shares were priced at $36.30, down 27.4% over the past year and lagging the S&P 500 by 39.18 percentage points, indicating market concerns regarding its evolving profitability model.
- Profitability Shift: Instacart's profitability increasingly relies on advertising revenue rather than delivery fees, as consumer packaged goods companies pay to promote products within the app, offering significantly higher margins, which may influence investor perceptions of its future value.
- Market Competition: As more retailers join the Instacart platform and brands increase marketing spend, advertising inventory grows with transaction volume, potentially strengthening Instacart's position in the grocery ecosystem and reducing reliance on delivery economics.
See More
GoDaddy Listed Among 13 Most Undervalued S&P 500 Stocks
- Price Target Cuts: Evercore ISI lowered its price target on GoDaddy from $145 to $95 while maintaining an In Line rating, indicating market caution regarding the company's future growth prospects.
- Revenue Guidance Miss: Citi reduced its price target from $195 to $110 but kept a Buy rating, noting that the 2026 revenue guidance fell short of expectations, highlighting potential in GoDaddy's new offerings.
- Earnings Report: GoDaddy reported Q4 EPS of $1.80, exceeding the consensus of $1.59, while Q4 revenue matched expectations at $1.27 billion, demonstrating the company's ability to maintain stable revenue.
- Growth Slowdown: Cantor Fitzgerald cut its price target from $130 to $90, citing a slowdown in bookings growth to 5% due to a new go-to-market strategy and domain promotions, with Q1 and FY26 revenue growth guidance slightly below prior estimates.
See More
Bullish Thesis on GoDaddy Inc. Highlights Investment Opportunity
- Stable Cash Flow: GoDaddy Inc. owns over 84 million domains, and despite a roughly 50% decline in market capitalization over the past year, its free cash flow remains robust, with expectations to generate between $1.2 billion and $1.6 billion, supporting buybacks and potential debt reduction.
- Share Repurchase Strategy: Since 2022, GoDaddy has reduced its share count by over 25%, creating a self-reinforcing growth engine through aggressive buyback programs, even in the absence of extraordinary organic growth.
- Market Mispricing: The market currently misprices GoDaddy as a commoditized registrar facing structural growth risks, underestimating the value of its recurring cash flows and repurchase program, with base-case valuations suggesting upside to $24 billion.
- Risks and Opportunities: While risks such as leverage constraints, AI-driven platform changes, and competitive pricing pressures exist, GoDaddy's sticky revenue and disciplined capital allocation offer an attractive risk/reward profile for investors.
See More
GoDaddy Under Investigation for Possible Securities Law Violations
- Financial Performance Disclosure: GoDaddy's Q4 2025 financial results, released on February 24, 2026, revealed bookings of $1.28 million, with the introduction of a promotional price for .com domains leading to a decline in upfront bookings and near-term revenue, indicating competitive pressures in the market.
- Revenue Guidance Downgrade: The company provided 2026 revenue guidance of $5.195 billion to $5.275 billion, anticipating a modest impact on revenue growth rates in both Core Platform and A&C segments due to the promotional pricing, suggesting strategic adjustments in response to market dynamics.
- Significant Stock Price Drop: Following the earnings report, GoDaddy's stock price fell by $13.16, or 14.26%, closing at $79.14 on February 25, 2026, reflecting investor concerns regarding the company's future performance.
- Investor Rights Protection: Glancy Prongay Wolke & Rotter LLP has initiated an investigation into GoDaddy to protect investor rights, encouraging affected investors to pursue claims, highlighting the law firm's commitment to safeguarding shareholder interests.
See More
