CLF Should I Buy
-
$
0.000
0.000(0.000%)
At close0.000(0.000%)Aft-market
ET
Cleveland-Cliffs is not a good buy right now for a Beginner long-term investor with $50,000-$100,000 to deploy. The stock has some near-term support from better Q1 revenue and the Palantir AI partnership, but the bigger picture is still mixed: profitability remains weak, guidance has disappointed, insiders are selling aggressively, and analyst targets have generally come down. For an impatient investor who does not want to wait for a better entry, this is not the clean buy you want today.
CLF is trading near 10.19, just below the prior close of 10.20, with modest weakness in after-hours and pre-market sentiment. The MACD histogram is positive but contracting, RSI_6 around 60.9 is neutral-to-mildly bullish, and moving averages are converging, which suggests the stock is stabilizing rather than starting a strong uptrend. Price is sitting above the pivot at 9.884 and below resistance at 10.667, with next resistance at 11.151. Short-term pattern analysis points to weak follow-through: +0.46% next day but -3.09% next week and -4.26% next month. Overall, the technical picture is neutral and not a strong entry setup.
["Q1 revenue increased 6.33% YoY to 4.922B.", "Stock rose 8.86% after Q1 results beat revenue expectations and losses narrowed.", "Three-year Palantir agreement could improve operational efficiency and data integration.", "Steel pricing and tariff-related supply constraints may support sector conditions."]
["Net income remains negative at -237M and EPS fell sharply year over year.", "Gross margin deteriorated significantly, showing weak profitability.", "Analyst targets have been cut by Morgan Stanley, Citi, JPMorgan, and BofA over recent months.", "Insiders are selling, with insider selling up sharply over the last month.", "CEO Lourenco Goncalves sold a large amount of stock after weak guidance and a disappointing quarter.", "Proposed DOJ settlement costs 12M and adds another headline risk.", "Short-term pattern analysis points to negative returns over the next week and month."]
In Q1 2026, Cleveland-Cliffs posted revenue of 4.922B, up 6.33% YoY, which shows solid top-line growth. However, profitability remains poor: net income was -237M, EPS was -0.42, and gross margin turned more negative year over year. This means the latest quarter season was better on sales but still weak on earnings quality and margin health. For a long-term beginner investor, the company is not yet showing the kind of durable earnings trend that supports an immediate buy.
Analyst sentiment has been mostly cautious to mixed, with several firms cutting price targets recently. Morgan Stanley and Citi both lowered targets but Morgan Stanley kept Overweight while Citi stayed Neutral. JPMorgan also cut its target and remained Neutral, Goldman Sachs initiated with Neutral, and BofA stayed Neutral with concern about the balance sheet. The pros view is that steel pricing, tariff support, and demand in infrastructure can help the sector, while the cons view is that CLF still has weaker free cash flow, balance-sheet pressure, and inconsistent earnings power versus peers. Overall Wall Street is not bearish across the board, but it is clearly not strongly bullish either.
