Based on the comprehensive data analysis, Nike (NKE) appears to be overvalued for the following reasons:
Technical Analysis: NKE's stock has declined significantly from its peak of $170 in 2021 to current levels around $76, showing persistent downward momentum and weak technical indicators.
Fundamental Concerns: The company's revenue declined 8% year-over-year in Q2 FY2025, with NIKE Brand Digital sales dropping 21% and wholesale revenues falling 3%.
Valuation Assessment: Despite trading at a lower P/E ratio of 22x compared to historical levels, NKE still commands a premium valuation given its deteriorating fundamentals and intensifying competition from brands like Hoka and On Holding.
Growth Outlook: Management projects a low double-digit revenue decline and significant gross margin deterioration for Q3 FY2025, indicating continued operational challenges ahead.
Leadership Transition: While new CEO Elliott Hill's return may eventually help stabilize operations, the turnaround will likely take considerable time as Nike rebuilds wholesale relationships and refreshes its product pipeline.